Balancing Planning and Preparation with Divine Sovereignty

The concept of balancing planning and preparation with divine sovereignty is rooted in biblical teachings that emphasize both human responsibility and God's overarching control. Proverbs 16:1 states, "It is the part of man to prepare the soul: and of the Lord to govern the tongue" ^[1]. This verse highlights the interplay between human effort and divine providence.

The biblical emphasis on preparation is evident in various passages. Sirach 18:23 advises, "Before prayer prepare thy soul" ^[2]. Similarly, II Timothy 3:17 notes that the man of God should be "well-prepared" for every good work ^[3]. The idea of preparation is also linked to the concept of God's sovereignty, as seen in Romans 9:22-23, where Paul writes about God preparing vessels unto glory ^[6].

In Christian theology, the relationship between human preparation and divine sovereignty has been a subject of debate. According to Aquinas, human preparation for grace is both from God as the mover and from free will as being moved. one tradition argues that while human preparation is necessary, it is not sufficient to guarantee grace, as the gift of grace exceeds human power ^[4].

Reformed theologians like Charles Hodge and John Calvin have also grappled with this issue. Hodge asserts that God's sovereignty in the distribution of providential blessings and religious advantages is undeniable, and that Augustinianism affirms this sovereignty ^[5]. Calvin, interpreting Romans 9:22-23, attributes supreme sovereignty to God's wrath and power, emphasizing that God's judgments are beyond human calculation ^[6].

The Puritan tradition, represented by Matthew Henry, emphasizes the need for preparation through repentance and faith in anticipation of God's favor. Henry notes that the voice crying in the wilderness calls people to prepare for the coming deliverance ^[7].

In contrast, the Eastern Orthodox tradition, as represented by John of Damascus, focuses on the union of human and divine elements in the person of Christ. While not directly addressing the balance between planning and divine sovereignty, John of Damascus highlights the cooperation between the divine and human aspects in Christ's nature ^[8].

The biblical concept of preparation is closely tied to the idea of foresight or providence. Aquinas discusses the virtue of providence as a part of prudence, arguing that it involves setting means in due order to an end. However, he distinguishes between divine providence, which governs all things, and human providence, which is limited to what is subject to human reason and power ^[11].

Ultimately, the balance between planning and preparation with divine sovereignty reflects the complex interplay between human responsibility and God's overarching control. As John Gill notes, the preparations of the heart in man are dependent on God's governance, highlighting the need for a nuanced understanding of the relationship between human effort and divine sovereignty ^[10].

The scriptural emphasis on both preparation and divine sovereignty underscores the importance of trusting in God's providence while still taking responsibility for one's actions. As the biblical narrative and theological traditions demonstrate, this balance is not always easy to maintain, but it is essential for a deep understanding of the Christian faith.

The patristic tradition also offers insights into this balance. Tertullian, for example, personifies Wisdom as a second person, emphasizing God's plan and disposition in creation ^[9]. This personification highlights the idea that God's sovereignty is not opposed to human preparation but is, in fact, the foundation for it.

Sources

Proverbs “Proverbs 16:1 (DRC) — It is the part of man to prepare the soul: and of the Lord to govern the tongue.”
Sirach “Sirach 18:23 (DRC) — Before prayer prepare thy soul: and be not as a man that tempteth God.”
II Timothy “II Timothy 3:17 (Rotherham) — In order that, ready, may be the man, of God, unto every good work, being well-prepared.”
theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, First Part of the Second Part (Prima Secundae), Of the Cause of Grace, Art. 3: Article: Whether grace is necessarily given to whoever prepares himself for it, or to whoever does what he can? I answer that, As stated above (Article [2]), man's preparation for grace is from God, as Mover, and from the free-will, as moved. Hence the preparation may be looked at in two ways: first, as it is from free-will, and thus there is no necessity that it should obtain grace, since the gift of grace exceeds every preparation of human power. But it may be considered, secondly, as it”
CCEL (Reformed (Old Princeton)) “Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Vol. 2, section 67: that they hear against the providence of God. This has already been shown. It is useless and irrational to argue against facts. It can avail 350 nothing to say that it is unjust in God to deal more favourably with one nation than with another, with one individual than with another, if in point of fact He acts as a sovereign in the distribution of his favours. That He does so act is undeniable so far as providential blessings and religious advantages are concerned. And this is all that Augustinianism asserts in regard to the dispensations ”
CCEL (Reformed) “John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, section 78: he might make known the riches of his glory on the vessels of mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory,” ( Rom. 9:22, 23 ). Let my readers observe that Paul, to cut off all handle for murmuring and detraction, attributes supreme sovereignty to the wrath and power of God; for it were unjust that those profound judgments, which transcend all our powers of discernment, should be subjected to our calculation. It is frivolous in our opponents to reply, that God does not altogether reject those whom in levity he tolerates, but remai”
Isaiah (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Isaiah 40:3: The time to favour Zion, yea, the set time, having come, the people of God must be prepared, by repentance and faith, for the favours designed them; and, in order to call them to both these, we have here the voice of one crying in the wilderness, which may be applied to those prophets who were with the captives in their wilderness-state, and who, when they saw the day of their deliverance dawn, called earnestly upon them to prepare for it, and assured them that all the difficulties which stood in the way of their deliverance should be got over. It is a good sign t”
CCEL (Eastern Orthodox) “John of Damascus, An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, section 61: and the holy mind was joined to the energising divinity of the Word, perceiving and knowing what was being accomplished. And thus His divinity communicates its own glories to the body while it remains itself without part in the sufferings of the flesh. For His flesh did not suffer through His divinity in the same way that His divinity energised through the flesh. For the flesh acted as the instrument of His divinity. Although, therefore, from the first conception there was no division at all between the two forms 2156 215”
Schaff ANF/NPNF (Patristic) “ANF Vol 3: Tertullian — CHAP. VI.--THE WORD OF GOD IS ALSO THE WISDOM OF GOD. THE GOING FORTH OF WISDOM TO CREATE THE UNIVERSE, ACCORDING TO THE DIVINE PLAN.: This power and disposition[1] of the Divine Intelligence[2] is set forth also in the Scriptures under the name of <greek>Sofia</greek>, Wisdom; for what can be better entitled to the name of Wisdom[3] than the Reason or the Word of God? Listen therefore to Wisdom herself, constituted in the character of a Second Person: "At the first the Lord created me as the beginning of His ways, with a view to His own works, before He made the earth,”
Proverbs (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Proverbs 16 (introduction): The preparations of the heart in man,.... The sense of these words, according to our version, depends upon the next clause, and the meaning of the whole is, that a man can neither think nor speak without God: the "orderings" or "marshallings of the heart" (a), as it may be rendered; that is, of the thoughts of the heart, which are generally irregular and confused; the ranging them in order, as an army in battle array, or as things regularly placed on a well furnished table; the fixing them on any particular subject, though about things civil and natural”
theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part (Secunda Secundae), Of Each Quasi-integral Part of Prudence, Art. 6: Article: Whether foresight* should be accounted a part of prudence? [*"Providentia," which may be translated either "providence" or "foresight."] I answer that, As stated above (Question [47], Article [1], ad 2, Articles [6],13), prudence is properly about the means to an end, and its proper work is to set them in due order to the end. And although certain things are necessary for an end, which are subject to divine providence, yet nothing is subject to human providenc”

Ask Your Own Question