Biblical Ethics of Stealing When Starving
The biblical ethics of stealing when starving is a complex issue that has been debated by various Christian traditions and Jewish rabbinic thought. Proverbs 6:30 suggests that stealing to satisfy hunger is not entirely condemned, as it states, "Men do not despise a thief, if he stealeth to satisfy his soul when he is hungry" [1]. This passage implies that the motivation behind the theft is taken into account.
In the Catholic tradition, Thomas Aquinas argues that in cases of extreme necessity, stealing to survive is not considered a sin. According to Aquinas, "things which are of human right cannot derogate from natural right or Divine right" and therefore, "man's needs have to be remedied by means of these very things" [5]. This view is based on the idea that the natural order established by Divine Providence ordains inferior things for the purpose of succoring man's needs.
The Baptist/Reformed tradition, as represented by John Gill, interprets Proverbs 6:30 as excusing theft only when done out of extreme necessity and not out of malice or greed [4]. Gill's commentary suggests that the thief is not entirely absolved of guilt but is rather pitied for their circumstances.
In contrast, the Reformed (Old Princeton) tradition, as represented by Charles Hodge, takes a more nuanced view. Hodge argues that the value of a thing is determined by its worth to the person who demands it, and therefore, it is not unfair to demand a high price for something that is essential to someone's survival [6]. This view implies that stealing to survive is not justified if the person has the means to pay for the thing they need.
Jewish rabbinic thought, as represented by the Babylonian Talmud, also grapples with the issue of stealing when starving. The Talmud suggests that one who steals to satisfy their hunger is not entirely condemned, but is rather expected to minimize their actions and not indulge in luxuries [7, 8].
The early Christian fathers, such as Augustine, emphasize the importance of charity and generosity towards those in need. Augustine notes that the apostle Paul collected relief for the brethren in Judea and that the necessaries presented to him were considered a form of alms-giving [9].
The biblical text itself provides various laws and teachings related to theft and poverty. The law prohibits theft and provides penalties for those who steal (Exodus 20:15; 22:1-4) [2]. The prophets also condemn theft and emphasize the importance of treating the poor with kindness and generosity (Isaiah 1:23; Jeremiah 7:9-10) [3].
Sources
- Proverbs “Proverbs 6:30 (Webster) — [Men] do not despise a thief, if he stealeth to satisfy his soul when he is hungry;”
- Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Theft — Punished by restitution, the proportions of which are noted in 2 Sam. 12:6. If the thief could not pay the fine, he was to be sold to a Hebrew master till he could pay (Ex. 22:1-4). A night-thief might be smitten till he died, and there would be no blood-guiltiness for him (22:2). A man-stealer was to be put to death (21:16). All theft is forbidden (Ex. 20:15; 21:16; Lev. 19:11; Deut. 5:19; 24:7; Ps. 50:18; Zech. 5:3; Matt. 19:18; Rom. 13:9; Eph. 4:28; 1 Pet. 4:15).”
- Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Theft — Is an abomination -- Jer 7:9,10. Forbidden -- Ex 20:15; Mr 10:19; Ro 13:9. From the poor specially forbidden -- Pr 22:2. Includes fraud in general -- Le 19:13. Includes fraud concerning wages -- Le 19:13; Mal 3:5; Jas 5:4. Proceeds from the heart -- Mt 15:19. Defiles a man -- Mt 15:20. The wicked Addicted to. -- Ps 119:61. Store up the fruits of. -- Am 3:10. Lie in wait to commit. -- Ho 6:9. Commit, under shelter of the night. -- Job 24:14; Ob 1:5. Consent to show who commit. -- Ps 50:18. Associate with those who commit. -- Isa 1:23. May, for a season, prospe”
- Proverbs (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Proverbs 6:29: Men do not despise a thief, if he steal,.... They do not discommend or reproach him for it, or fix a mark of infamy upon him, or expose him to public shame by whipping him; but rather excuse him and pity him when it appears what his case is, what put him upon it, and that he had no other intention in it than to do as follows; to satisfy his soul; his craving appetite for food, having nothing to eat, nor no other way of getting any: the words should be supplied thus, "for he does this to satisfy his soul"; or, as the Syriac version, "for he steals to satisfy his so”
- theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part (Secunda Secundae), Of Theft and Robbery, Art. 7: Article: Whether it is lawful to steal through stress of need? I answer that, Things which are of human right cannot derogate from natural right or Divine right. Now according to the natural order established by Divine Providence, inferior things are ordained for the purpose of succoring man's needs by their means. Wherefore the division and appropriation of things which are based on human law, do not preclude the fact that man's needs have to be remedied by means of these very things. H”
- CCEL (Reformed (Old Princeton)) “Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Vol. 3, section 50: what it is worth to the man who demands it; or what it will bring in open market. If an hour’s use of the horse and wagon was worth more to the man in Chicago than a thousand dollars, it may be said that it was not unfair to demand that sum. If this be so, then if a man perishing of thirst is willing to give his whole estate for a glass of water, it would be right to exact that price; or if a man in danger of drowning should offer a thousand dollars for a rope, we might refuse to throw it to him for a less reward. Such conduct every man f”
- Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Taanit 62a.20:6: With regard to one who forgot the fast and ate and drank, he should not show himself before the community while satiated, and he should not indulge in luxuries. One should not think that because one has already eaten, his fast is completely nullified, and one may conduct himself as if it were not a fast day at all. Rather, one should minimize one’s eating, as it is stated: “And Jacob said to his sons: Why do you show yourselves?” (Genesis 42:1). Jacob said to his sons: Do not show yourselves when you are satiated, not before the members of the house of Esau,”
- Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Taanit 10b.6: With regard to one who forgot the fast and ate and drank, he should not show himself before the community while satiated, and he should not indulge in luxuries. One should not think that because one has already eaten, his fast is completely nullified, and one may conduct himself as if it were not a fast day at all. Rather, one should minimize one’s eating, as it is stated: “And Jacob said to his sons: Why do you show yourselves?” (Genesis 42:1). Jacob said to his sons: Do not show yourselves when you are satiated, not before the members of the house of Esau, no”
- Schaff ANF/NPNF (Patristic) “NPNF1 Vol 6: Augustine — Homilies on the Gospels — CHAP. XVII.--56. For in the case of those who are seeking first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, i.e. who are preferring this to all other things, so that for its sake they are seeking the o (part 2): Caesar. Then the disciples, every one according to his ability, determined to send relief to the elders for the brethren which dwelt in Judaea, which also they did by the hands of Barnabas and Saul."[5] And in the case of the necessaries presented to him, wherewith the same Apostle Paul when setting sail was laden,[6] food seems to have”