Biblical Perspective on Playing the Lottery

The Bible does not directly address modern lottery systems, but it provides principles and examples concerning the casting of lots, which was a common practice in ancient Israel. The primary biblical understanding of lots is that their outcome is ultimately controlled by God, as stated in Proverbs 16:33: "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from Yahweh" ^[1]. This perspective suggests that while humans may initiate the process, the divine hand guides the result ^[9].

The Biblical Use of Lots

In ancient Israel, lots were used for various purposes, often with the expectation that God would direct the outcome ^[3]. These uses were distinct from modern gambling and were frequently sanctioned or even commanded by God for specific religious or administrative functions.

One significant use of lots was to discern God's will or to make important decisions. Examples include:

Dividing Land: After the conquest of Canaan, the land was divided among the tribes of Israel by lot, as seen in Joshua 14:2 and 18:6-10 ^{[10, 14]}. Isaiah 34:17 describes God casting the lot for His people and dividing their inheritance ^[2].
Identifying Guilt: Lots were used to identify individuals responsible for certain transgressions. For instance, in 1 Samuel 14:40-43, lots were cast to discover who had violated Saul's oath ^[10]. Similarly, in the book of Jonah, lots were cast to determine who was responsible for the storm, leading to the identification of Jonah ^[17].
Selecting Priests and Temple Duties: Lots were employed to assign responsibilities within the Temple service. The Babylonian Talmud describes the High Priest drawing lots to determine which goat would be sacrificed "for the Lord" and which "for Azazel" on the Day of Atonement, emphasizing that the lottery, not verbal designation, made the goat a sin-offering ^{[11, 13, 15, 16]}. The Talmud also notes that lotteries were desirable to cause a "commotion in the House of God," indicating their sacred context ^{[7, 8]}.
Choosing Leaders: In the selection of Matthias to replace Judas Iscariot, the apostles cast lots, praying for God to show them His choice (Acts 1:26) ^[17].

These biblical instances highlight that the casting of lots was often a solemn act, undertaken with a belief in divine oversight, rather than a game of chance for personal gain ^{[10, 14]}. The practice was seen as a means for God to reveal His will or to ensure impartiality in critical decisions ^[3].

Theological Perspectives on Chance and Providence

The concept of "chance" in the modern sense, where outcomes are purely random and devoid of divine influence, is not explicitly present in the biblical understanding of lots. Instead, the biblical worldview emphasizes God's sovereignty over all events, including those that appear random to human observers ^[9]. John Calvin, in his Institutes of the Christian Religion, cites Jeremiah 10:23 and Proverbs 20:24 to argue that "the way of man is not in himself" and "man’s goings are of the Lord," reinforcing the idea that God directs human steps and outcomes ^[9].

Thomas Aquinas, in his Summa Theologica, discusses "sortilege" (divination by lots) and distinguishes between different uses. He defines sortilege as "doing something, that by observing the result one may come to the knowledge of something unknown" ^[12]. Aquinas identifies "sortilege of allotment" as seeking to know what is to be given to whom, whether it be a possession, honor, or punishment ^[12]. This aligns with the biblical uses of lots for distribution and decision-making, where the outcome was believed to be divinely determined.

Distinguishing Biblical Lots from Modern Lotteries

Modern lotteries, particularly those run by governments or commercial entities, differ significantly from the biblical practice of casting lots in several key aspects:

Purpose: Biblical lots were primarily used for discerning God's will, making impartial decisions, or assigning sacred duties ^{[10, 14, 17]}. Modern lotteries are typically designed as a form of entertainment and a means of raising revenue, often for public services, with the primary motivation for participants being financial gain.
Motivation: Participants in modern lotteries are driven by the hope of winning a large sum of money ^[5]. While the Bible encourages hope in God and His promises ^[5], it does not endorse seeking wealth through games of chance.
Reliance on Providence vs. Chance: While the biblical understanding of lots explicitly states that "its every decision is from Yahweh" ^[1], modern lotteries operate on the principle of statistical probability and random chance. The expectation in biblical lot-casting was divine intervention; in modern lotteries, it is mathematical odds.
Potential for Harm: Modern lotteries can lead to addictive behaviors, financial distress for individuals and families, and a misplaced hope for sudden wealth rather than diligent work or reliance on God's provision ^[6]. The Bible encourages waiting upon God for temporal blessings and salvation ^[4], and warns against self-delusion regarding prosperity ^[6].

While the Bible does not explicitly condemn all forms of gambling, the principles it upholds—such as responsible stewardship of resources, avoiding the love of money, and seeking God's will—provide a framework for evaluating participation in modern lotteries. The focus on divine providence in the casting of lots in Scripture stands in contrast to the purely probabilistic nature of commercial lotteries.

Sources

Proverbs “The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from Yahweh. -- Proverbs 16:33”
Isaiah “He has cast the lot for them, and his hand has divided it to them with a measuring line. They shall possess it forever. From generation to generation they will dwell in it. -- Isaiah 34:17”
Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: Lot — (literally a pebble). The custom of deciding doubtful questions by lot is one of great extent and high antiquity. Among the Jews lots were used with the expectation that God would so control them as to give a right direction to them. They were very often used by God's appointment. "As to the mode of casting lots, we have no certain information. Probably several modes were practiced." "Very commonly among the Latins little counters of wood were put into a jar with so narrow a neck that only one could come out at a time. After the jar had been filled with water an”
Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Waiting Upon God — As the God of providence -- Jer 14:22. As the God of salvation -- Ps 25:5. As the Giver of all temporal blessings -- Ps 104:27,28; Ps 145:15,16. For Mercy. -- Ps 123:2. Pardon. -- Ps 39:7,8. The consolation of Israel. -- Lu 2:25. Salvation. -- Ge 49:18; Ps 62:1,2. Guidance and teaching. -- Ps 25:5. Protection. -- Ps 33:20; 59:9,10. The fulfillment of His word. -- Hab 2:3. The fulfillment of His promises. -- Ac 1:4. Hope of righteous by faith. -- Ga 5:5. Coming of Christ. -- 1Co 1:7; 1Th 1:10. Is good -- Ps 52:9. God calls us to -- Zep 3:8. Exhortat”
Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Hope — In God -- Ps 39:7; 1Pe 1:21. In Christ -- 1Co 15:19; 1Ti 1:1. In God's promises -- Ac 26:6,7; Tit 1:2. In the mercy of God -- Ps 33:18. Is the work of the Holy Spirit -- Ro 15:13; Ga 5:5. Obtained through Grace. -- 2Th 2:16. The word. -- Ps 119:81. Patience and comfort of the Scriptures. -- Ro 15:4. The gospel. -- Col 1:5,23. Faith. -- Ro 5:1,2; Ga 5:5. The result of experience -- Ro 5:4. A better hope brought in by Christ -- Heb 7:19. Described as Good. -- 2Th 2:16. Lively. -- 1Pe 1:3. Sure and steadfast. -- Heb 6:19. Gladdening. -- Pr 10:28. Blessed. -- Tit ”
Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Self-Delusion — A characteristic of the wicked -- Ps 49:18. Prosperity frequently leads to -- Ps 30:6; Ho 12:8; Lu 12:17-19. Obstinate sinners often given up to -- Ps 81:11,12; Ho 4:17; 2Th 2:10,11. Exhibited in thinking that Our own ways are right. -- Pr 14:12. We should adhere to established wicked practices. -- Jer 44:17. We are pure. -- Pr 30:12. We are better than others. -- Lu 18:11. We are rich in spiritual things. -- Re 3:17. We may have peace while in sin. -- De 29:19. We are above adversity. -- Ps 10:6. Gifts entitle us to heaven. -- Mt 7:21,22. Privileges ”
Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 25a.7: And if it were to enter your mind to say the opposite, that the chamber stood entirely in the non-sacred area, how could the lottery be held in the east? Aren’t we required to fulfill the verse: “In the House of God we walked with the throng” (Psalms 55:15), from where it was derived earlier that it is desirable that the lotteries cause a commotion in the House of God, i.e., in the sacred area of the Temple? If the lottery were held in a non-sacred area, there would not be a fulfillment of this verse. Rather, one must conclude from this baraita that the chamber w”
Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 176a.49:7: And if it were to enter your mind to say the opposite, that the chamber stood entirely in the non-sacred area, how could the lottery be held in the east? Aren’t we required to fulfill the verse: “In the House of God we walked with the throng” (Psalms 55:15), from where it was derived earlier that it is desirable that the lotteries cause a commotion in the House of God, i.e., in the sacred area of the Temple? If the lottery were held in a non-sacred area, there would not be a fulfillment of this verse. Rather, one must conclude from this baraita that the chamb”
CCEL (Reformed) “John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, section 32: chiefly for the sake of mankind that the world was made, we must look to this as the end which God has in view in the government of it. The prophet Jeremiah exclaims, “O Lord, I know that the way of man is not in himself: it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps,” ( Jer. 10:23 ). Solomon again says, “Man’s goings are of the Lord: how can a man then understand his own way?” ( Prov. 20:24 ). Will it now be said that man is moved by God according to the bent of his nature, but that man himself gives the movement any direction”
Proverbs (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Proverbs 16:33: 16:33 We may throw the dice: These dice were not for gambling but were a means commissioned by God to determine his will (Exod 28:30; see also Josh 14:2; 1 Sam 10:17-27; 14:40-43).”
Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 176a.80:10: Come and hear a proof that Rabbi Yehuda holds that the drawing of the lots is indispensable. A baraita in the Sifra teaches: The verse states: “Aaron shall bring forward the goat upon which the lot came up for the Lord, and he shall offer it for a sin-offering” (Leviticus 16:9). The verse indicates that the lottery makes it a sin-offering, but verbally designating the goat with the status of a sin-offering does not make it a sin-offering.”
theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part (Secunda Secundae), Of Superstition in Divinations, Art. 8: Article: Whether divination by drawing lots is unlawful? I answer that, As stated above (Article [3]), sortilege consists, properly speaking, in doing something, that by observing the result one may come to the knowledge of something unknown. If by casting lots one seeks to know what is to be given to whom, whether it be a possession, an honor, a dignity, a punishment, or some action or other, it is called "sortilege of allotment"; if one seeks to know what ought to be done, it”
Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 40b.10: Come and hear a proof that Rabbi Yehuda holds that the drawing of the lots is indispensable. A baraita in the Sifra teaches: The verse states: “Aaron shall bring forward the goat upon which the lot came up for the Lord, and he shall offer it for a sin-offering” (Leviticus 16:9). The verse indicates that the lottery makes it a sin-offering, but verbally designating the goat with the status of a sin-offering does not make it a sin-offering.”
Proverbs (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Proverbs 18:18: 18:18 Flipping a coin (literally Casting lots): Casting lots was a valid way of seeking God’s will (Num 27:21; Josh 18:6-10). The Lord determined how the lots would fall (Prov 16:33).”
Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 39a.6: MISHNA: The High Priest would mix the lots in the lottery receptacle used to hold them and draw the two lots from it, one in each hand. Upon one was written: For God. And upon the other one was written: For Azazel. The deputy High Priest would stand to the High Priest’s right, and the head of the patrilineal family would stand to his left. If the lot for the name of God came up in his right hand, the Deputy would say to him: My master, High Priest, raise your right hand so that all can see with which hand the lot for God was selected. And if the lot for the name ”
Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 176a.77:6: MISHNA: The High Priest would mix the lots in the lottery receptacle used to hold them and draw the two lots from it, one in each hand. Upon one was written: For God. And upon the other one was written: For Azazel. The deputy High Priest would stand to the High Priest’s right, and the head of the patrilineal family would stand to his left. If the lot for the name of God came up in his right hand, the Deputy would say to him: My master, High Priest, raise your right hand so that all can see with which hand the lot for God was selected. And if the lot for the n”
Jonah (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Jonah 1:7: 1:7-8 Use of lots was permitted by God for certain purposes (see Lev 16:8; Josh 18:6; 1 Chr 26:12-16; Acts 1:26); however, divination in general, as practiced in the wider ancient world, was displeasing to the Lord (Deut 18:9-13). • to see which of them had offended the gods: It was fairly common in the ancient Near East to assume that bad fortune was the result of a god’s taking offense.”

Ask Your Own Question