BEREAN.AI ← Ask a Question

Bodily Assumption of Mary Doctrine

The doctrine of the Bodily Assumption of Mary posits that at the end of her earthly life, the Virgin Mary was taken, body and soul, into heavenly glory. This belief is a defined dogma within the Roman Catholic Church. While not explicitly stated in canonical Scripture, Thomas Aquinas, a prominent scholastic theologian, argued that it could be reasonably inferred, much like Mary's sanctification before birth, which is also not detailed in the Bible [3].

The Catholic Church formally defined the Assumption as dogma in 1950, though the belief has ancient roots. Eastern Orthodox traditions also affirm the Dormition (falling asleep) of the Theotokos, which shares many similarities with the Assumption, emphasizing her bodily translation into heaven.

Protestant traditions generally do not accept the doctrine of the Bodily Assumption of Mary. Reformed theologians like John Calvin, while affirming Mary's role as the mother of Christ, emphasized that Christ's true humanity was derived from her [4]. Charles Hodge, another Reformed theologian, similarly stressed that Christ's birth from a woman meant he was born in the same sense as other humans, essential for his true humanity [1]. However, these traditions do not extend this understanding to include Mary's bodily assumption into heaven. The Augsburg Confession, a foundational Lutheran document, affirms that the Son of God "did assume the human nature in the womb of the blessed Virgin Mary," emphasizing the incarnation but not Mary's post-mortem bodily state [5].

The absence of direct biblical testimony is a primary reason for the rejection of the doctrine in many Protestant confessions. While the resurrection of the body is a widely held Christian doctrine [2], its application to Mary specifically, apart from the general resurrection, is not found in their scriptural interpretations. The mystery of Christ's incarnation itself is often described as something to be adored rather than fully comprehended [6].

Sources

  1. CCEL (Reformed (Old Princeton)) “Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Vol. 2, section 126: substance of the Virgin Mary.” This is involved in the Scriptural statement that He was born of a woman, which can only mean that He was born in the sense in which other children of men are born of women. This is essential to his true humanity, and to that likeness to men which makes them his brethren, and which was se cured by his taking part in flesh and blood. ( Heb. ii. 14 .) The incarnation of the Son of God, his stooping to take into personal and perpetual union with Himself a nature infinitely lower than his own, was an act of uns”
  2. CCEL (Reformed (Old Princeton)) “Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Vol. 3, section 82: § 2. History of the Doctrine. The doctrine of the resurrection of the body is not exclusively a doctrine of the Bible. It is found, in different forms, in many of the ancient religions of the world. This is the more remarkable as it is in itself so improbable, and so much out of the analogy of nature. One generation of plants and animals succeeds another in uninterrupted succession; but the same individuals never reappear. The case is the more remarkable when we consider the difficulties with which the doctrine is beset; difficulties so g”
  3. theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Third Part (Tertia Pars), Of the Sanctification of the Blessed Virgin, Art. 1: Article: Whether the Blessed Virgin was sanctified before her birth from the womb? I answer that, Nothing is handed down in the canonical Scriptures concerning the sanctification of the Blessed Mary as to her being sanctified in the womb; indeed, they do not even mention her birth. But as Augustine, in his tractate on the Assumption of the Virgin, argues with reason, since her body was assumed into heaven, and yet Scripture does not relate this; so it may be reasonably argued that she was ”
  4. CCEL (Reformed) “John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, section 49: declaring him to be “God blessed for ever,” he mentions separately, that, “as concerning the flesh, he was descended from the Jews.” Again if he had not been truly begotten of the seed of David, what is the meaning of the expression, that he is the “fruit of his loins;” or what the meaning of the promise, “Of the fruit of thy body will I set upon thy throne?” ( Ps. 132:11 ). Moreover their mode of dealing with the genealogy of Christ, as given by Matthew, is mere sophistry; for though he reckons up the progenitors not of Mary, but ”
  5. Augsburg Confession (Lutheran) “Augsburg Confession (Lutheran, 1530), 1 Also they teach that the Word, that is, the Son of God, did: 1 Also they teach that the Word, that is, the Son of God, did assume the human nature in 2 the womb of the blessed Virgin Mary, so that there are two natures, the divine and the human, inseparably enjoined in one Person, one Christ, true God and true man, who was born of the Virgin Mary, truly suffered, was crucified, dead, and 3 buried, that He might reconcile the Father unto us, and be a sacrifice, not only for original guilt, but also for all actual sins of men.”
  6. Matthew (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Matthew 1:18: The mystery of Christ's incarnation is to be adored, not pried into. If we know not the way of the Spirit in the formation of common persons, nor how the bones are formed in the womb of any one that is with child (Ecc 11:5), much less do we know how the blessed Jesus was formed in the womb of the blessed virgin. When David admires how he himself was made in secret, and curiously wrought (Psa 139:13-16), perhaps he speaks in the spirit of Christ's incarnation. Some circumstances attending the birth of Christ we find here which are not in Luke, though it is more la”
Ask Your Own Question