Identity of Gaius in 3 John and Epistles
The Third Epistle of John is addressed to an individual named Gaius, whom the author, identified as "the elder," loves "in truth" [1, 2]. While the epistle itself does not provide extensive biographical details about Gaius, biblical scholars and commentators have considered whether this Gaius is one of several other individuals bearing the same common name in the New Testament [3, 4, 5].
The New Testament mentions at least three other men named Gaius:
- Gaius of Macedonia: This individual was a traveling companion of Paul and was seized by a mob in Ephesus along with Aristarchus when they could not find Paul [3, 5, 7].
- Gaius of Derbe: He accompanied Paul into Asia on his final journey to Jerusalem [3, 5, 6].
- Gaius of Corinth: Paul baptized this Gaius and stayed at his home in Corinth when writing the Epistle to the Romans [3, 5, 9]. Paul refers to him as "mine host" in Romans 16:23 [3, 11].
The question of whether the Gaius of 3 John is identical to any of these other figures remains uncertain [4]. Some commentators suggest that the Gaius of 3 John might be the same as the Gaius of Derbe [5]. Others, like Matthew Henry, consider it possible that he is the same Gaius mentioned by Paul in Romans 16:23 [13]. John Gill, a Baptist/Reformed commentator, notes the agreement in character, particularly their hospitality, between Paul's host and the Gaius of 3 John, but suggests they lived in different locations and times, with John's Gaius being in Asia near Ephesus [10, 11].
The Third Epistle portrays Gaius as a beloved Christian known for his faithfulness and hospitality [1, 13]. The elder commends Gaius for his practice of "walking in truth" and for showing love and support to traveling Christian "brothers" (likely emissaries of John) who were strangers to him [12, 14]. These traveling teachers spread the Gospel and encouraged believers [12]. Gaius's hospitality extended to these individuals, even those from different churches, demonstrating his sincerity in faith [14]. The elder expresses great joy upon hearing reports of Gaius's adherence to the apostolic gospel and his charitable actions [12, 14].
The epistle also contrasts Gaius's conduct with that of Diotrephes, who refused to receive the elder's emissaries and even cast out those who did [15]. This suggests that Gaius was a prominent and respected layman, possibly of wealth, in a church near Ephesus, where John likely resided in his later years [8, 10]. The elder's purpose in writing was to commend these traveling Christians to Gaius and to encourage his continued support for their ministry [4, 14]. The epistle implies that Gaius was a convert of John, as the elder expresses joy in seeing his "children" (spiritual offspring) walk in truth [8, 14].
Sources
- III John “III John 1:1 (Geneva1599) — The Elder vnto the beloued Gaius, whom I loue in the trueth.”
- 3 John “3 John 1:1 (NASB) — The elder to the beloved Gaius, whom I love in truth.”
- Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Gaius — (1.) A Macedonian, Paul's fellow-traveller, and his host at Corinth when he wrote his Epistle to the Romans (16:23). He with his household were baptized by Paul (1 Cor. 1:14). During a heathen outbreak against Paul at Ephesus the mob seized Gaius and Aristarchus because they could not find Paul, and rushed with them into the theatre. Some have identified this Gaius with No. (2). (2.) A man of Derbe who accompanied Paul into Asia on his last journey to Jerusalem (3.) A Christain of Asia Minor to whom John addressed his third epistle (3 John 1:1).”
- Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: John, Third Epistle of — Is addressed to Caius, or Gaius, but whether to the Christian of that name in Macedonia (Acts 19: 29) or in Corinth (Rom. 16:23) or in Derbe (Acts 20:4) is uncertain. It was written for the purpose of commending to Gaius some Christians who were strangers in the place where he lived, and who had gone thither for the purpose of preaching the gospel (ver. 7). The Second and Third Epistles were probably written soon after the First, and from Ephesus.”
- Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: Gaius — or Cai'us (lord)-- + A Macedonian who accompanied Paul in his travels, and whose life was in danger from the mob at Ephesus. (Acts 19:29) (A.D. 54.) + Of Derbe. He went with Paul from Corinth in his last journey to Jerusalem. (Acts 20:4) (A.D. 54.) + Of Corinth, whom Paul baptized and who was his host in his second journey in that city. (1 Corinthians 1:14; Romans 16:23) (These are supposed by some to be only one person.) + John's third epistle is addressed to Christian of this name. We may possibly identify him with No. 2.”
- STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=G1050H — Man living at the time of the New Testament (refs: #A man living at the time of the New Testament, only mentioned at Act.20.4; <br>only referred to as )”
- STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=G1050G — Man living at the time of the New Testament (refs: #A man living at the time of the New Testament, only mentioned at Act.19.29; <br>only referred to as)”
- Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: John, The Second And Third Epistles Of — The second epistle is addressed to an individual woman. One who had children, and a sister and nieces, is clearly indicated. According to one interpretation she is "the Lady Electa," to another, "the elect Kyria," to a third, "the elect Lady." The third epistle is addressed to Caius or Gaius. He was probably a convert of St. John, Epist. (3 John 1:4) and a layman of wealth and distinction, Epits. (3 John 1:5) in some city near Ephesus. The object of St. John in writing the second epistle was to warn the lady to whom he wrote ag”
- STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=G1050I — Man living at the time of the New Testament (refs: #A man living at the time of the New Testament, first mentioned at Rom.16.23; <br>only referred to a)”
- 3 John (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on 3 John 1 (introduction): The elder unto the well beloved Gaius,.... The elder is the writer of the epistle, the Apostle John, who so styles himself on account of his age, and office, as in the preceding epistle. The person to whom he writes is "the well beloved Gaius"; not that Gaius, who was the Apostle Paul's host, Rom 16:23, for though their characters agree, being both hospitable men, yet neither the place nor time in which they lived. The Apostle Paul's Gaius lived at Corinth, this is in some place near to Ephesus, for the apostle in his old age purposed to come and see him s”
- Romans (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Romans 16:22: Gaius mine host,.... There was one Gaius a Macedonian, that was with the apostle at Ephesus, Act 19:29; and another Gaius of Derbe, that accompanied him into Asia, Act 20:4; whether either of these, as the latter seems more probable, was this person, is not certain. However, it seems very likely that it is the same Gaius the apostle baptized at Corinth, Co1 1:14; and some have thought him to be the same that the Apostle John wrote his third epistle to, and indeed the characters of hospitality and generosity there given him well agree with this, who was not only the a”
- 3 John (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 3 John 1:3: 1:3 The traveling teachers (literally brothers) were probably John’s emissaries who traveled from church to church, teaching the Good News and encouraging Christians (see 1:5, 10). • you are living according to the truth: Gaius was faithful to the apostolic gospel of Jesus Christ. The false teachers denied the reality of the incarnation or the sacrificial death of Jesus Christ (cp. 1 Jn 4:1-3).”
- 3 John (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on 3 John 1:1: I. The sacred penman writes and sends the letter, referred to as "The elder," meaning by years and office, deserving honor. Some question whether this was John the apostle, but his style and spirit are evident. Gaius could not question who wrote it. John humbly refers to himself as "the elder," aligning with ordinary church pastors. II. The recipient is Gaius, a well-beloved individual, possibly the same Gaius mentioned by Paul in Romans 16:23. John expresses his love for him "in the truth," for walking in truth, which shows true love rooted in the gospel. III. Joh”
- 3 John (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on 3 John 1:3: I. John receives a good report of Gaius's faith and charity from the brethren. Gaius’s love for the brethren and hospitality to strangers proves his sincerity in the faith. II. Gaius is commended for his hospitality, a virtue extended to strangers and those of different churches. III. John expresses great joy in hearing of Gaius's walk in truth. This reflects the joy of ministers when they see their followers living out their faith. IV. John advises Gaius to continue supporting the brethren by aiding them on their journeys in a godly manner, reflecting Christian ge”
- 3 John (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on 3 John 1:9: I wrote unto the church,.... Where Gaius was a member: those who take Gaius to be the same with Paul's host, and whom he baptized at Corinth, think the church at Corinth is here meant; but it seems rather to be meant of some church in Asia nearer Ephesus; nor is it likely that John's first epistle should be here intended, which makes no mention of relieving the brethren, the ministers of the Gospel, that came from Judea: and that this epistle should not be preserved, need not seem strange; for it cannot be thought that everything that was written by him to particular p”