Jerusalem City Gate Called Eye Of Needle

The notion of a "needle's eye" gate in Jerusalem, often cited in popular interpretations of Jesus' teaching about a rich man entering the kingdom of God, is not supported by biblical or historical evidence ^{[1, 14]}. This interpretation suggests that a small gate, through which a camel could only pass with difficulty after being unburdened, existed in Jerusalem and was known as the "eye of a needle" ^[1]. However, scholarly consensus indicates that this explanation is "ill-conceived" and that no such gate ever existed ^[14]. Instead, Jesus' teaching in Matthew 19:24, Mark 10:25, and Luke 18:25—"it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God"—is understood as a literal hyperbole, emphasizing the extreme difficulty riches pose to spiritual entry into God's kingdom ^{[1, 14]}.

While the "eye of a needle" gate is a misconception, Jerusalem did possess numerous gates throughout its history, many of which are mentioned in biblical texts, particularly in the book of Nehemiah, which details the rebuilding of the city walls. These gates served various functions and were named for their direction, purpose, or nearby features.

Some of the historically attested gates of Jerusalem include:

The Sheep Gate: This gate was located in the eastern wall of the city ^[7]. Nehemiah 3:1 and 32, and 12:39 mention it, placing it between the Tower of Meah and the chamber of the corner ^{[10, 11]}. Some traditions suggest it was near the Bab el Kattanin ^[11]. Matthew Henry, a Nonconformist commentator, speculates that Christ might have ridden through this gate in triumph into Jerusalem, connecting it to the "tower of the flock" mentioned in Micah 4:8 ^[18].
The Fish Gate: Mentioned in Nehemiah 3:3 and 12:39, this gate was situated on the east of the lower city, north of the Sheep Gate ^{[15, 16, 19]}. Rashi, a prominent Jewish commentator, notes that there was a gate in Jerusalem called by this name ^[15]. John Gill, a Baptist commentator, suggests it was rebuilt by the sons of Hassenaah after the Babylonian captivity ^[16]. Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown indicate that it was near the stronghold of David in Milo, between Zion and the lower city, towards the west, and was named for the fish market nearby, through which fish from the Sea of Galilee and Jordan were brought ^[19]. It is also suggested that Nebuchadnezzar entered the city through this gate ^[19].
The Old Gate (or Yeshanah Gate): This gate was located in the north wall of Jerusalem ^{[5, 6]}. It is mentioned in Nehemiah 3:6 and 12:39 and was called "Old" because it was built by the Jebusites ^[6].
The Dung Gate: Referenced in Nehemiah 2:13, this gate was also in Jerusalem ^[4].
The Gate of Ephraim: This gate was located on the north side of the city, facing the tribe of Ephraim ^{[13, 20]}. It is mentioned in 2 Kings 14:13, 2 Chronicles 25:23, Nehemiah 8:16, and 12:39 ^[13]. John Gill notes that King Jehoash of Israel broke down the wall of Jerusalem from the Gate of Ephraim to the Corner Gate, a distance of four hundred cubits ^[20]. Its position is thought to be near the present-day Damascus Gate ^[13].
The Corner Gate: This gate is mentioned in 2 Kings 14:13 and Zechariah ^[9].
The Muster Gate (or Miphkad Gate): Nehemiah 3:31 refers to this gate ^[3]. Smith's Bible Dictionary suggests it was likely not in the wall of Jerusalem proper but in that of the City of David, or Zion, near the junction of the two on the north side ^[8].
The Guard Gate: This gate is mentioned in Nehemiah 12:39 ^[2].

Ezekiel's vision of the future city also describes gates, though these are symbolic and represent the twelve tribes of Israel. Ezekiel 48:31 states, "And the gates of the city are according to the names of the tribes of Israel; three gates northward: the gate of Reuben one, the gate of Judah one, the gate of Levi one" ^[12]. John Gill interprets these gates as signifying open and free access for all people into the church of Christ in the latter days, with people flocking from all directions ^[17].

The absence of any historical or archaeological evidence for a "needle's eye" gate underscores the importance of interpreting biblical hyperbole literally in such contexts. Jesus' statement about the camel and the needle's eye is a vivid illustration of the spiritual challenge wealth presents, rather than a reference to a specific architectural feature of Jerusalem ^[14].

Sources

Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Needle — Used only in the proverb, "to pass through a needle's eye" (Matt. 19:24; Mark 10:25; Luke 18:25). Some interpret the expression as referring to the side gate, close to the principal gate, usually called the "eye of a needle" in the East; but it is rather to be taken literally. The Hebrew females were skilled in the use of the needle (Ex. 28:39; 26:36; Judg. 5:30).”
STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=H4307G — Gate of the Guard= in Jerusalem ([email protected]=H3389) (refs: #A location in <strong="H3389">Jerusalem only mentioned at Neh.12.39; only referred to )”
STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=H4663 — Muster Gate= in Jerusalem ([email protected]=H3389) (refs: #A location in <strong="H3389">Jerusalem first mentioned at Neh.3.31; referred to as <s)”
STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=H0830G — Dung Gate= in Jerusalem ([email protected]=H3389) (refs: #A location in <strong="H3389">Jerusalem first mentioned at Neh.2.13; only referred to )”
STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=H3465G — Gate of Yeshanah= in Jerusalem ([email protected]=H3389) (refs: #A location in <strong="H3389">Jerusalem first mentioned at Neh.3.6; referred to as <st)”
Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Old gate — One of the gates in the north wall of Jerusalem, so called because built by the Jebusites (Neh. 3:6; 12:39).”
Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Sheep-gate — One of the gates of Jerusalem mentioned by Nehemiah (3:1, 32; 12:39). It was in the eastern wall of the city.”
Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: Miphkad — (appointed place), The gate, one of the gates of Jerusalem. (Nehemiah 3:31) It was probably not in the wall of Jerusalem proper, but in that of the city of David, or Zion, and somewhere near to the junction of the two on the north side.”
STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=H6438G — Corner Gate= in Jerusalem ([email protected]=H3389) (refs: #A location in <strong="H3389">Jerusalem first mentioned at 2Ki.14.13; referred to as <)”
STEPBible TIPNR “Biblical proper name: [email protected]=H6629H — Sheep Gate= in Jerusalem ([email protected]=H3389) (refs: #A location in <strong="H3389">Jerusalem first mentioned at Neh.3.1; referred to as <st)”
Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: Sheepgate, The — one of the gates of Jerusalem as rebuilt by Nehemiah. (Nehemiah 3:1,32; 12:39) It stood between the tower of Meah and the chamber of the corner, ch. (Nehemiah 3:1,32) or gate of the guard-house, ch. (Nehemiah 12:39) Authorized Version, "prison-gate." The latter seems to have been at the angle formed by the junction of the wall of the city of David with that of the city of Jerusalem proper, having the sheep-gate on the north of it. The position of the sheep-gate may therefore have been on or near that of the Bab el Kattanin.”
Ezekiel “Ezekiel 48:31 (YLT) — And the gates of the city <FI>are<Fi> according to the names of the tribes of Israel; three gates northward: the gate of Reuben one, the gate of Judah one, the gate of Levi one.”
Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: Ephraim, Gate Of — one of the gates of the city of Jerusalem, (2 Kings 14:13; 2 Chronicles 25:23; Nehemiah 8:16; 12:39) probably at or near the position of the present "Damascus gate."”
Mark (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Mark 10:25: 10:25 Jesus was emphatically warning that riches are an obstacle to entering the Kingdom of God. The camel was the largest animal in Palestine, the eye of a needle the smallest hole. Some rich people are evidently able to overcome the problem created by riches and follow Jesus, but Jesus’ followers came from among the poor more than from the rich. • Explanations about a gate in the Jerusalem wall called the “Eye of the Needle” are ill-conceived. There never was such a gate, and this explanation loses sight of Jesus’ frequent use of hyperbole in his teaching (see al”
Sefaria (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki) on Zephaniah 1:10: from the fish gate Jonathan renders: from the gate of the fish; there was a gate in Jerusalem called by that name.”
Zephaniah (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Zephaniah 1:10: And it shall come to pass in that day, saith the Lord, &c.] In the day of the Lord's sacrifice, when he shall punish the inhabitants of Judah and Jerusalem by the Chaldeans; which, as well as what follows, shall surely come to pass, because the Lord has said it; for not one word of his shall pass away, but all be fulfilled: [that there shall be] the noise of a cry from the fish gate; a gate of the city of Jerusalem so called, which suffered as the rest in the destruction of the city by the Babylonians, and, after the captivity, was rebuilt by the sons of Hassenaah,”
Ezekiel (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Ezekiel 48:27: At the west side four thousand and five hundred,.... Measures or reeds; so many were the length of this side; the same with north, south, and east, and made a foursquare; and such the city was, as the New Jerusalem is said to be, Rev 21:16, with their three gates: one gate of Gad, one gate of Asher, one gate of Naphtali; the situation of these gates on all sides, east, west, north, and south, show that in the latter day people will flock from all quarters to the church of Christ, and that there will be an open and free access of all persons into it; see Isa 2:2.”
Micah (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Micah 4:8: These verses relate to Zion and Jerusalem, here called the tower of the flock or the tower of Edor; we read of such a place (Gen 35:21) near Bethlehem; and some conjecture it is the same place where the shepherds were keeping their flocks when the angels brought them tidings of the birth of Christ, and some think Bethlehem itself is here spoken of, as Mic 5:2. Some think it is a tower at that gate of Jerusalem which is called the sheep-gate (Neh 3:32), and conjecture that through that gate Christ rode in triumph into Jerusalem. However, it seems to be put for Jerusa”
Zephaniah (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on Zephaniah 1:10: fish gate-- (Ch2 33:14; Neh 3:3; Neh 12:39). Situated on the east of the lower city, north of the sheep gate [MAURER]: near the stronghold of David in Milo, between Zion and the lower city, towards the west [JEROME]. This verse describes the state of the city when it was besieged by Nebuchadnezzar. It was through the fish gate that he entered the city. It received its name from the fish market which was near it. Through it passed those who used to bring fish from the lake of Tiberias and Jordan. It answers to what is now called the Damascus gate [HE”
2 Kings (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on 2 Kings 14:11: And Jehoash king of Israel took Amaziah king of Judah, the son of Jehoash the son of Ahaziah, at Bethshemesh,.... And then they looked one another in the face indeed, but Amaziah must look very silly: and came to Jerusalem; the metropolis of Judah, with his royal prisoner: and broke down the wall of Jerusalem; in at the breach of which he went with his chariot, as Josephus says (e), in triumph: from the gate of Ephraim unto the corner gate, four hundred cubits; the gate of Ephraim was to the north of the city, towards the tribe of Ephraim, from whence it had i”

Ask Your Own Question