BEREAN.AI ← Ask a Question

Managing In-Law Visits After Husband's Conversion

In Jewish tradition, the conversion of a spouse can significantly alter the legal and social dynamics of a marriage, particularly concerning familial relationships. For instance, the status of in-laws after a conversion is a matter of rabbinic discussion. One view, attributed to Rabbi Yishmael, holds that a convert's mother-in-law remains forbidden to him even after his wife's death, similar to the prohibition during her lifetime. This strict interpretation aims to prevent a convert from marrying a Jewish-born mother-in-law. Conversely, Rabbi Akiva's opinion permits the convert to maintain his mother-in-law, suggesting a more lenient approach to such prohibitions [3].

Maimonides clarifies that if a man and his wife convert, and they were married to certain forbidden relations (like a mother or sister) while gentile, they must separate. However, if they were married to other forbidden relations, even maternal ones, they are not forced to separate after conversion, as their marriage predates their conversion [5]. This indicates that while some pre-existing relationships are nullified by conversion, others are upheld. Furthermore, Maimonides notes that if a man marries a female convert and her daughter, or two maternal sisters who converted, he must remain married to one and divorce the other, a rabbinic decree to align with the stringencies applied to native-born Jews [7].

Regarding the practical aspects of in-law visits, Jewish law grants a husband the prerogative to limit his in-laws' access to his home. A husband can state, "I do not desire that your father, your mother, your brothers and your sisters come into my domain." In such cases, the wife is expected to visit her family only for significant events or once a month and on festivals, while her family should visit her only for major occurrences like sickness or birth [6]. This principle underscores the husband's authority over his household and the boundaries he can set for external family interactions.

In early Christian thought, the conversion of one spouse in a marriage to an unbeliever also presented unique challenges. Tertullian discusses the case of a heathen whose wife converts after marriage, noting that such women are "apprehended by God" in their circumstances and are encouraged to persevere in their married state, with the hope of "making a gain" (i.e., converting their husbands) [2]. He further suggests that if an apostle permitted remarriage after the loss of a partner post-conversion, it would be a condescension to human hard-heartedness, similar to Mosaic divorce permissions [4]. Aquinas, from a scholastic perspective, states that if an unbelieving spouse is willing to cohabit without attempting to draw the believer to unbelief, the believer is free to part but not to remarry. However, if the unbeliever refuses to cohabit without insulting the Creator, the believer is free to separate and remarry [1]. These perspectives highlight the complexities of maintaining marital and familial ties when one spouse undergoes a significant religious conversion.

Sources

  1. theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Supplement (Supplementum), Of Disparity of Worship As an Impediment to Marriage, Art. 5: Article: Whether the believer who leaves his unbelieving wife can take another wife? I answer that, When either husband or wife is converted to the faith the other remaining in unbelief, a distinction must be made. For if the unbeliever be willing to cohabit without insult to the Creator---that is without drawing the other to unbelief---the believer is free to part from the other, but by parting is not permitted to marry again. But if the unbeliever refuse to cohabit without insu”
  2. Schaff ANF/NPNF (Patristic) “ANF Vol 4: Tertullian IV, Minucius Felix, Commodian, Origen — CHAP, VII.--THE CASE OF A HEATHEN WHOSE WIFE IS CONVERTED AFTER MARRIAGE WITH HIM VERY DIFFERENT, AND MUCH MORE HOPEFUL.: If these things may happen to those women also who, having attained the faith while in (the state of) Gentile matrimony, continue in that state, still they are excused, as having been "apprehended by God"[8] in these very circumstances; and they are bidden to persevere in their married state, and are sanctified, and have hope of "making a gain"[9] held out to them. "If, then, a marriage of this kind (contracted b”
  3. Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 98b.7: The one who prohibits the convert from maintaining his mother-in-law is in accordance with the opinion of Rabbi Yishmael, who said that one’s mother-in-law after his wife’s death remains forbidden to him to the same degree as during her lifetime. And therefore, with regard to a convert, the Sages decreed that she is forbidden to him, lest one marry his mother-in-law who is a Jew from birth after his wife’s death. And the one who permits him to maintain her is in accordance with the opinion of Rabbi Akiva, who said that the prohibition against engaging in inter”
  4. Schaff ANF/NPNF (Patristic) “ANF Vol 4: Tertullian IV, Minucius Felix, Commodian, Origen — CHAP. XIV.--EVEN IF THE PERMISSION HAD BEEN GIVEN BY ST. PAUL IN THE SENSE WHICH THE PSYCHICS ALLEGE, IT WAS MERELY LIKE THE MOSAIC PERMISSION OF DIVORCE--A CONDESCENSION TO HUMAN HARD-HEARTEDNESS. (part 1): Now, if the apostle had even absolutely permitted marriage when one's partner has been lost subsequently to (conversion to) the faith, he would have done (it), just as (he did) the other (actions) which he did adversely to the (strict) letter of his own rule, to suit the circumstances. of the times: circumcising Timotheus[5] on ”
  5. Mishneh Torah (Maimonides) (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Mishneh Torah (Maimonides), Mishneh Torah%2C Forbidden Intercourse 14:13: What is the law that applies to converts with regard to relations with their relatives. As we explained, if one was married while a gentile to his mother or his sister and they converted, we separate them as explained [above]. If he was married to any one of the other forbidden relations and he and his wife converted, they are not forced to separate. 29 This applies even to maternal relatives. Since they were married before, we do not force them to separate ( Siftei Cohen 269:2). We do not fear that these converts will s”
  6. Mishneh Torah (Maimonides) (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Mishneh Torah (Maimonides), Mishneh Torah%2C Marriage 13:14: When a person tells his wife, "I do not desire that your father, your mother, your brothers and your sisters come into my domain," he is given that prerogative. Instead, she should visit them when an [unusual] event occurs to them. And she should visit her father's house once a month and on each festival. They, by contrast, should visit her only when an unusual event of great import occurs - e.g., sickness or birth. For a person should not be forced to have others enter his domain. Similarly, if [the wife] says: "I do not want your m”
  7. Mishneh Torah (Maimonides) (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Mishneh Torah (Maimonides), Mishneh Torah%2C Forbidden Intercourse 14:15: When a man marries a female convert and her daughter who converted or two maternal sisters [who converted], he should remain married to one of them and divorce the other. 36 This is a Rabbinic decree. According to Scriptural Law, the marriages are valid. Nevertheless, our Rabbis were stringent and forbade this union, for were the women to be native-born Jewesses, this would be forbidden. Hence, formal divorce proceedings are necessary. If he married a female convert and she died, he is permitted to marry her mother or he”
Ask Your Own Question