Navigating Family Conflict Over Sister's Sexual Orientation
Navigating Family Conflict Over a Sister's Sexual Orientation
The biblical prohibition against sexual relations between siblings is clearly stated in Leviticus 18:9 and 20:17 [1, 2]. These passages emphasize the severity of the prohibition, with Leviticus 20:17 prescribing that those who engage in such relations "must be cut off in the sight of their people" [1].
Historically, the prohibition against sibling relationships has been interpreted in various ways. Augustine argued that the purpose of such prohibitions was to widen the circle of social affections, promoting a broader sense of community and familial bonds [5]. According to Augustine, when siblings marry outside their immediate family, it extends the network of relationships and fosters greater social cohesion [7].
In Jewish tradition, the prohibition against sibling relationships is also taken seriously. The Babylonian Talmud discusses the severity of the prohibition and the liability for sin offerings in cases where individuals unwittingly engage in forbidden relationships, including with a sister [4, 6, 8]. The Talmud highlights the complexity of these prohibitions and the need for careful interpretation.
When navigating family conflict over a sister's sexual orientation, it is essential to consider the historical and cultural context of biblical prohibitions. While the biblical text clearly prohibits sibling relationships, the application of this prohibition to modern contexts requires careful consideration of the complexities involved.
In contemporary discussions, the focus has shifted from merely applying ancient prohibitions to understanding the nuances of human relationships and the importance of compassion and understanding. The Tyndale House commentary on Song of Solomon 8:8-10 highlights the importance of protecting a sister's chastity in ancient Near Eastern culture, demonstrating that the concern for familial relationships and sexual purity is not new [3].
Sources
- Leviticus “Leviticus 20:17 (BSB) — If a man marries his sister, whether the daughter of his father or of his mother, and they have sexual relations, it is a disgrace. They must be cut off in the sight of their people. He has uncovered the nakedness of his sister; he shall bear his iniquity.”
- Leviticus “Leviticus 18:9 (BSB) — You must not have sexual relations with your sister, either your father’s daughter or your mother’s daughter, whether she was born in the same home or elsewhere.”
- Song of Solomon (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Song of Solomon 8:8: 8:8-10 In the midst of a passionate exchange of romantic compliments and commitments, here again is strong praise for sexual abstinence until marriage. 8:8 We have a little sister: The wife’s brothers express concern for their sister’s chastity. According to ancient Near Eastern custom, they are the protectors of their sister’s sexuality until her marriage.”
- Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Keritot 2b.30: The Gemara asks: Why is it necessary for the verse to separate the transgressions and render one liable to bring a separate sin offering with regard to these forbidden relatives? Aren’t they separate categories of prohibitions, and aren’t they separate bodies, i.e., three different people? It is obvious that each act of intercourse will require a separate sin offering. Rather, say as follows: The verse serves to separate the transgressions and render one liable to bring a separate sin offering for unwittingly engaging in intercourse with his sister who is also”
- CCEL (Reformed (Old Princeton)) “Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Vol. 3, section 49: vol. ii. arts. 104-108, pp. 54-76. 409 Augustine’s Theory. Augustine advanced a theory on this subject, which still has its earnest advocates. He held that the design of all these prohibitory laws was to widen the circle of the social affections. Brothers and sisters are bound together by mutual love. Should they intermarry the circle is not extended. If they choose husbands and wives from among strangers, a larger number of persons are included in the bonds of mutual love. “ Habita est ratio rectissima charitatis, ut homines quibus esset”
- Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Keritot 57b.4:30: The Gemara asks: Why is it necessary for the verse to separate the transgressions and render one liable to bring a separate sin offering with regard to these forbidden relatives? Aren’t they separate categories of prohibitions, and aren’t they separate bodies, i.e., three different people? It is obvious that each act of intercourse will require a separate sin offering. Rather, say as follows: The verse serves to separate the transgressions and render one liable to bring a separate sin offering for unwittingly engaging in intercourse with his sister who is a”
- Schaff ANF/NPNF (Patristic) “NPNF1 Vol 2: Augustine — City of God, Christian Doctrine — CHAP. 16.--OF MARRIAGE BETWEEN BLOOD-RELATIONS, IN REGARD TO WHICH THE PRESENT LAW COULD NOT BIND THE MEN OF THE EARLIEST AGES. (part 3): in the course of generations diverge, and become distant relationship, or cease to be relationship at all, religiously endeavored to limit it by the bond of marriage before it became distant, and thus, as it were, to call it back when it was escaping them. And on this account, even when the world was full of people, though they did not choose wives from among their sisters or half-sisters, yet they p”
- Babylonian Talmud (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Babylonian Talmud, Keritot 57a.4:30: The Gemara asks: Why is it necessary for the verse to separate the transgressions and render one liable to bring a separate sin offering with regard to these forbidden relatives? Aren’t they separate categories of prohibitions, and aren’t they separate bodies, i.e., three different people? It is obvious that each act of intercourse will require a separate sin offering. Rather, say as follows: The verse serves to separate the transgressions and render one liable to bring a separate sin offering for unwittingly engaging in intercourse with his sister who is a”