BEREAN.AI ← Ask a Question

Perversion and God-Dismissal in Luke 17

Luke 17:17 presents a poignant question from Jesus: "Were not ten cleansed? Where are the nine?" (ESV). This verse concludes the narrative of Jesus healing ten lepers, highlighting the ingratitude of the nine who failed to return and give thanks, in contrast to the one Samaritan who did [6]. The passage immediately precedes Jesus' discourse on the coming of the kingdom of God, initiated by a question from the Pharisees [6].

The broader context of Luke 17 begins with Jesus teaching his disciples about the seriousness of causing others to stumble (offences) and the importance of forgiveness [5, 6]. He warns that "it is impossible but that offences will come: but woe unto him, through whom they come!" (Luke 17:1, KJV) [5]. This teaching on moral responsibility sets a tone for understanding the subsequent narrative of the lepers, where a failure to acknowledge God's grace could be seen as a form of spiritual stumbling or perversion.

The term "perverted" (Greek: diastrephō) is used elsewhere in the Gospels to describe a generation lacking faith and morally corrupt [7]. In Matthew 17:17, Jesus exclaims, "O faithless and perverted generation! How long will I be with you? How long shall I bear with you?" (LITV) [2]. This expression often refers to moral depravity, as seen in Deuteronomy 32:5, 19-22, and is typically directed at those who refuse to acknowledge God's presence [7]. While in Matthew 17:17 it criticizes the disciples' lack of trust, in the context of Luke 17:17, the nine lepers' failure to return thanks can be interpreted as a form of spiritual perversion—a turning away from God despite receiving His miraculous intervention. Their physical cleansing was not accompanied by spiritual gratitude.

The concept of "God-dismissal" is implicitly present in the actions of the nine lepers. Their failure to return and glorify God, despite being miraculously healed, signifies a dismissal of the divine source of their healing. This resonates with themes found in other scriptures. For instance, Romans 1:21 speaks of those who, "when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened" (KJV) [3]. This lack of gratitude and acknowledgment of God's work can be seen as a form of spiritual blindness or forgetfulness, akin to forgetting "the covenant of her God" as mentioned in Proverbs 2:17 (LITV) [1].

The healing of the ten lepers itself is significant. In Jewish tradition, leprosy was often associated with various sins, including idol worship, forbidden sexual relations, bloodshed, blasphemy, and slander [8]. While Jesus does not explicitly link the lepers' condition to specific sins in this passage, their healing represents a profound act of divine mercy and power. The expectation for the healed to show themselves to the priests (Luke 17:14) was part of the Mosaic law for reintegration into society, but Jesus' question emphasizes a deeper spiritual obligation: gratitude to God [6].

The contrast between the nine Jewish lepers and the one Samaritan is also crucial. Samaritans were often viewed with disdain by Jews, yet it is the Samaritan who demonstrates true faith and gratitude [6]. This highlights a recurring theme in Luke's Gospel, where outsiders or marginalized individuals often exhibit greater spiritual insight or responsiveness than those within the religious establishment [4]. The Samaritan's return to give thanks with a "loud voice" (Luke 17:15, KJV) and falling "down on his face at his feet, giving him thanks" (Luke 17:16, KJV) exemplifies proper worship and acknowledgment of God's grace.

Sources

  1. Proverbs “Proverbs 2:17 (LITV) — who forsakes the guide of her youth and forgets the covenant of her God.”
  2. Matthew “Matthew 17:17 (LITV) — And answering, Jesus said, O faithless and perverted generation! How long will I be with you? How long shall I bear with you? Bring him here to Me.”
  3. Treasury of Scripture Knowledge “Luke 17:17 cross-references: Genesis 3:9, Psalms 106:13, John 8:7, Romans 1:21”
  4. OpenBible.info “Cross-reference: Acts.13.47 → Luke.2.32 (confidence: 17 votes)”
  5. Luke (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Luke 17:1: We are here taught, I. That the giving of offences is a great sin, and that which we should every one of us avoid and carefully watch against, Luk 17:1, Luk 17:2. We can expect no other than that offences will come, considering the perverseness and frowardness that are in the nature of man, and the wise purpose and counsel of God, who will carry on his work even by those offences, and bring good out of evil. It is almost impossible but that offences will come, and therefore we are concerned to provide accordingly; but woe to him through whom they come, his doom will”
  6. Luke (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Luke 17 (introduction): In this chapter we have, I. Some particular discourses which Christ had with his disciples, in which he teaches them to take heed of giving offence, and to forgive the injuries done them (Luk 17:1-4), encourages them to pray for the increase of their faith (Luk 17:5, Luk 17:6), and then teaches them humility, whatever service they had done for God (Luk 17:7-10). II. His cleansing ten lepers, and the thanks he had from one of them only, and he a Samaritan (Luk 17:11-19). III. His discourse with his disciples, upon occasion of an enquiry of the Pharisees,”
  7. Matthew (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Matthew 17:17: 17:17 faithless and corrupt people: The expression is often used for moral depravity (see Deut 32:5, 19-22). Normally, this exclamation of Jesus was directed at the unbelieving Jewish crowds or leaders who refuse to acknowledge God’s presence in him (see Matt 12:39). Here, however, it was a sharp criticism of his disciples’ failure to trust Jesus and his saving, healing power.”
  8. Midrash Rabbah (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Midrash Rabbah, Vayikra Rabbah 17:3: For ten matters leprosy comes: For idol worship, for forbidden sexual relations, for bloodshed, for desecration of the Name, for blaspheming of the Name, for one who robs the public, for one who steals what is not his, for the haughty, for slander, and for miserliness. For idol worship – [this is derived] from [the precedent of] Israel, who bore false witness against the Holy One blessed be He and said regarding the calf: “This is your god, Israel” (Exodus 32:4). From where is it derived that they were afflicted with leprosy? As it is stated: “Moses saw the”
Ask Your Own Question