The Puritans Outlawed Christmas but Loved Thanksgiving
Episode 24 of the November series: Providence & Gratitude. Here's a reversal that breaks every modern assumption about these people: the Puritans outlawed Christmas — and loved Thanksgiving.
It was literally illegal.
On May 11, 1659, the Massachusetts Bay General Court passed a law fining anyone five shillings for observing Christmas "by forbearing of labour, feasting, or any other way." The law stood until it was repealed in 1681 (under pressure from the English crown, which wanted colonial law to match England's).
And this wasn't just a colonial quirk. Back in England, the Puritan-controlled Parliament had suppressed and then abolished the observance of Christmas in the 1640s, making Christmas Day an ordinary working day.
(Honest caveats: no records of actual prosecutions under the 1659 Massachusetts law have been found, and some historians note the ban was "as much political as religious" for many. But the theological reasoning is well-documented.)
Why would devout Christians ban Christmas?
Not because they hated Jesus — they loved Christ supremely. The objection was a principle about HOW God is to be worshiped.
The Puritans held what's called the "regulative principle of worship": that God is to be worshiped only in the ways He has commanded in Scripture, and that elements He has NOT commanded don't belong in worship. Their proof texts included the "strange fire" of Nadab and Abihu, struck down for offering worship God "commanded them not" (Leviticus 10:1-3), and "What thing soever I command you, observe to do it: thou shalt not add thereto" (Deuteronomy 12:32).
And nowhere does Scripture institute a feast of the Nativity, or command Christ's birth to be observed on December 25 (a date the Bible never gives). So to the Puritans, Christmas lacked warrant as a holy day. On top of that, they objected to the actual 17th-century practice of Christmas — a raucous season of drinking, gambling, and misrule (the "Lord of Misrule"), which they saw as having little of Christ and much of excess.
Here's the reversal.
The same people who banned Christmas gladly kept days of thanksgiving.
Why the difference? Because a day of thanksgiving (as we saw earlier this week) was not a fixed annual human invention — it was an occasional, providential response to God's acts, modeled on biblical precedent. It passed the regulative test. A fixed nativity feast, in their judgment, did not.
So flip your assumptions entirely. To the Puritans, Christmas was the suspicious holiday — and Thanksgiving was the biblical one.
And this is consistent with their whole approach.
The Puritans and Separatists rejected the ENTIRE calendar of man-appointed holy days — Christmas, Easter as a mandated holy day, saints' days, and Hallowmas (the root of Halloween). They recognized only the weekly Sabbath (the day God DID command) plus occasional days of fasting and thanksgiving. Same principle, applied across the whole calendar.
You don't have to agree with them.
This is important: the point here is NOT "the Puritans were right and you're sinning if you celebrate Christmas." Mainstream Reformed and evangelical Christians today celebrate Christmas joyfully and in good conscience, understanding it as a matter of Christian liberty (Romans 14:5-6; Colossians 2:16-17) rather than commanded worship. Many Reformed thinkers hold that a free, glad celebration of the incarnation — not imposed as mandatory worship — is fully legitimate and good.
The goal is to understand what drove them: a holy carefulness about the worship of God, a reluctance to add human inventions to what He commanded, and a greater fear of displeasing God than of missing a cultural festivity.
The enduring lesson.
Whatever you conclude about Christmas specifically, the Puritan instinct is worth respecting. They feared adding to God's worship more than they feared missing a party. That carefulness, rightly directed, is a guard against worship drifting into whatever the culture finds festive.
Sources: The 1659 Massachusetts law and its 1681 repeal (MassMoments.org; History.com; HistoryofMassachusetts.org); the English Parliament's 1640s suppression of Christmas; Westminster Confession 21.1 on the regulative principle of worship.
This is episode 24 of the 30-day November series. Tomorrow: Abraham Lincoln made Thanksgiving a national holiday in the middle of the bloodiest war in American history.
📖 Passages: Leviticus 10:1-3, Deuteronomy 4:2, 12:29-32, 1 Samuel 13:8-14, 15:22-23, 1 Kings 12:25-33, Isaiah 29:13, Matthew 15:8-9, Mark 7:6-9, Romans 14:1-12, Colossians 2:16-23, Hebrews 12:28-29, Revelation 22:18-19