BEREAN.AI ← Ask a Question

Reformed Puritan Exposition of Fifth Commandment

The Fifth Commandment, "Honor your father and your mother, that your days may be long in the land that the Lord your God is giving you" (Exodus 20:12, Deuteronomy 5:16) [5], is a cornerstone of Reformed and Puritan expositions on familial and social duties. According to John Calvin, this commandment is the first of the Second Table, emphasizing the importance of social relationships and duties towards others [1].

Biblical Foundation

The commandment is rooted in the biblical text, where it is presented as a fundamental principle for maintaining social order and ensuring the well-being of individuals within their communities. Calvin notes that the term "father" applies not only to biological parents but also to those in positions of authority and superiority, such as elders, magistrates, and pastors [1]. Charles Hodge expands on this, stating that the general principle of duty enjoined in this commandment is to feel and act in a becoming manner towards superiors, regardless of the nature of their superiority [2].

Reformed and Puritan Exposition

Reformed and Puritan theologians interpreted the Fifth Commandment as requiring three main aspects of honor towards parents and superiors: reverence, obedience, and gratitude [1]. Reverence involves showing respect and deference, obedience entails complying with legitimate commands and instructions, and gratitude requires acknowledging and appreciating the benefits and care received from those in authority.

Calvin emphasizes that the honor due to parents is not contingent upon their worthiness but is rather a reflection of the divine institution of family and authority structures. one tradition argues that even unworthy parents are to be honored, as the commandment is not based on the merits of the parents but on the divine ordinance [1]. This perspective is echoed in the writings of other Reformed theologians, who stress the importance of maintaining social order and respecting authority.

Patristic Antecedents

The early Church Fathers also addressed the Fifth Commandment, often in the context of broader discussions on Christian ethics and morality. For example, Augustine discusses the commandments in his works, sometimes following the division that includes the Fifth Commandment as part of the Second Table [4]. While the Patristic sources do not provide a uniform exposition on the Fifth Commandment, they underscore the importance of honoring authority and maintaining social harmony.

Contrasting Traditions

Lutheran tradition, as represented by Luther's Small Catechism, also emphasizes the importance of the Fifth Commandment, though the specific exposition may differ from Reformed and Puritan interpretations. Luther's Catechism explains the commandment in the context of obedience to authority and the maintenance of social order [3].

Historical Development

The exposition of the Fifth Commandment has developed over time, influenced by various theological and social factors. The Reformed and Puritan emphasis on the commandment reflects their broader theological commitments, including the importance of biblical authority and the role of the family in Christian society. The historical development of this doctrine is marked by its sharpening during the Reformation and Puritan eras, as theologians sought to articulate a distinctly Christian ethic in response to societal and ecclesiastical challenges.

The Reformed Puritan exposition of the Fifth Commandment remains significant, as it underscores the importance of respecting authority, maintaining social order, and cultivating gratitude and obedience towards those in positions of superiority. This exposition is grounded in a deep understanding of biblical teaching and reflects a commitment to applying these principles in the context of Christian community and society. As such, it continues to inform Christian ethics and practice, offering insights into the nature of authority, obedience, and social responsibility [1, 2, 5].

Sources

  1. CCEL (Reformed) “John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, section 44: to Judaism. Objection. 34. Ground of this institution. There is no kind of superstitious necessity. The sum of the Commandment. 35. The Fifth Commandment (the first of the Second Table), expounded. Its end and substance. How far honour due to parents. To whom the term father applies. 36. It makes no difference whether those to whom this honour is required are worthy 316 or unworthy. The honour is claimed especially for parents. It consists of three parts. 1. Reverence. 37. Honour due to parents continued. 2. Obedience. 3. Gratitude”
  2. CCEL (Reformed (Old Princeton)) “Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Vol. 3, section 47: § 9. The Fifth Commandment. Its Design. The general principle of duty enjoined in this commandment, is that we should feel and act in a becoming manner towards our superiors. It matters not in what their superiority consists, whether in age, office, power, knowledge, or excellence. There are certain feelings, and a certain line of conduct due to those who are over us, for that very reason, determined and modified in each case by the degree and nature of that superiority. To superiors are due, to each according to the relation in which he ”
  3. Luther's Small Catechism (Lutheran) “Luther's Small Catechism (Lutheran, 1529), The Fifth Commandment.: The Fifth Commandment.”
  4. CCEL (Reformed) “John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, section 44: expounding the Fifth Commandment. It is also adopted by Augustine, in his book addressed to Boniface, where, in enumerating the commandments, he follows this order, Let one God be religiously obeyed, let no idol be worshipped, let the name of God be not used in vain; while previously he had made separate mention of the typical commandment of the Sabbath. Elsewhere, indeed, he expresses approbation of the first division, but on too slight grounds, because, by the 326 number three (making the First Table consist of three commandments”
  5. Deuteronomy (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Deuteronomy 5:6: Here is the repetition of the ten commandments, in which observe, 1. Though they had been spoken before, and written, yet they are again rehearsed; for precept must be upon precept, and line upon line, and all little enough to keep the word of God in our minds and to preserve and renew the impressions of it. We have need to have the same things often inculcated upon us. See Phi 3:1. 2. There is some variation here from that record (Ex. 20), as there is between the Lord's prayer as it is in Mt. 6 and as it is Lu. 11. In both it is more necessary that we tie our”
Ask Your Own Question