Romans 6 Dead to Sin Yet Still Tempted
Romans 6: Understanding Death to Sin and Ongoing Temptation
Romans 6:2 states, "Let it not be! We who died to sin, how shall we still live in it?" [2]. This verse is part of Paul's argument against the idea that justification by faith leads to licentiousness. He emphasizes that believers have died to sin and should not continue living in it.
The literary context of Romans 6 is crucial. Paul has just finished discussing justification by faith in Romans 5 and anticipates the objection that if sin is forgiven, believers might as well continue sinning to receive more grace. He counters this by explaining the nature of dying to sin through union with Christ's death [3].
The phrase "dead to sin" does not mean believers are entirely insensitive to sin or temptation. Rather, it signifies a new relationship with sin made possible by Christ's death. Believers are no longer helpless slaves to sin; they can choose not to sin [3]. This concept is reinforced by John Gill, who notes that believers are "dead to sin" both as justified and sanctified individuals [5].
The historical setting of Romans is significant. Paul wrote to the Roman church, likely composed of Gentile and Jewish believers, to clarify the gospel and address potential misinterpretations. The apostle's discussion of dying to sin is part of his broader argument for living a holy life, motivated by gratitude for God's grace [6].
A key term in Romans 6 is "died to sin." This phrase is closely tied to the concept of union with Christ, as believers have died with Him and are now alive to God (Romans 6:8-11). Adam Clarke interprets "reckon ye also yourselves to be dead" as believers dying as truly unto sin as Christ died for sin, and living as truly unto God as Christ lives with God [9].
The major exegetical decision in Romans 6 revolves around understanding the nature of dying to sin. Commentators agree that it involves a change in the believer's relationship with sin, enabling them to resist sin's power. Jamieson, Fausset & Brown emphasize the importance of surrendering oneself to God and using one's members as instruments of righteousness [8].
Different traditions interpret Romans 6 in various ways. The Eastern Orthodox tradition, represented by John Chrysostom, focuses on the potential for misinterpretation of Paul's teachings on grace and the need to emphasize the importance of living a virtuous life [7]. Protestant academics, such as those represented in the Tyndale House commentary, highlight the significance of union with Christ in understanding the believer's death to sin [3, 4].
In Christian tradition, Romans 6 has been used to emphasize the importance of holiness and the possibility of resisting sin. The passage has functioned in various controversies, including debates over the nature of justification and the role of human agency in resisting sin.
The tension between being "dead to sin" and still being tempted is a recurring theme in Christian theology. As I Timothy 5:6 notes, "the one who lives for sensual pleasure is dead even though she lives" [1], highlighting the contrast between outward appearance and inner reality. Believers, though dead to sin, continue to face temptation, underscoring the need for ongoing vigilance and reliance on God's grace.
Sources
- I Timothy “I Timothy 5:6 (LEB) — But the one who lives for sensual pleasure is dead even though she lives.”
- Romans “Romans 6:2 (LITV) — Let it not be! We who died to sin, how shall we still live in it?”
- Romans (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Romans 6:2: 6:2 we have died to sin: As Paul makes clear in 6:3-10, our new relationship to sin is possible because of our vital connection with the death of Jesus. Just as dying means entrance into an entirely new state of being, our relationship with sin is now different because of Christ’s death. To be “dead to sin” does not mean to be entirely insensitive to sin and temptation—believers are still involved in a battle with sin (6:12-14). However, Christians no longer have to live as helpless slaves to sin; they can choose not to sin (6:6, 14, 16-22).”
- Romans (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Romans 6:10: 6:10 he died once to break the power of sin: Because we died with Jesus (6:4-5), we have also died to sin (6:2). Jesus was never under sin’s power in the way that we are, because he had no sin nature from Adam and he never succumbed to temptation (2 Cor 5:21; Heb 4:15). However, when he became human, he entered the arena where sin holds sway, and he was truly vulnerable to sin.”
- Romans (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Romans 6:2: God forbid,.... By which he expresses his abhorrence of such a practice, and that this was a consequence which did not follow from the premises, and was far enough from his thoughts, and which he had in the greatest detestation: and he further argues against it by asking, how shall we that are dead to sin, live any longer therein? There is a death for sin, a death in sin, and a death to sin; the latter is here mentioned, and persons may be said to be "dead to sin", both as justified and sanctified: justified persons are dead to sin, inasmuch as that is not imputed to”
- Romans (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on Romans 6 (introduction): INTRODUCTION TO ROMANS 6 The Apostle having finished his design concerning the doctrine of justification, refutes the charge brought against it as a licentious doctrine, and prevents any ill use that might be made of it by men of evil minds, justified persons by the strongest arguments, and with the best of motives to holiness of life and conversation: he saw, that whereas he had affirmed in the preceding chapter, that sin being made to abound by the law, in the condemnation of sinners, the grace of God the more abounded in their justification and pardon”
- CCEL/NPNF (Eastern Orthodox) “John Chrysostom, Homilies on Acts & Romans: offended at what he said, and therefore said, “I have written the more boldly unto you in some sort,” ( Rom. xv. 15 ) much more would he have seemed to them, had he not done so, to be too harsh. Since then he showed the greatness of the grace by the greatness of the sins it healed, and owing to this it seemed in the eyes of the unthinking to be an encouragement to sin (for if the reason, they would say, why greater grace was shown, was because we had done great sins, let us not give over sinning, that grace may be more displayed still), now that they”
- Romans (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on Romans 6:13: Neither yield ye your members instruments of unrighteousness unto Sin, but yield yourselves--this is the great surrender. unto God as those that are alive from the dead, and--as the fruit of this. your members--till now prostituted to sin. instruments of righteousness unto God--But what if indwelling sin should prove too strong for us? The reply is: But it will not.”
- Romans (Methodist/Wesleyan) “Adam Clarke on Romans 6:11: Reckon ye also yourselves to be dead - Die as truly unto sin, as he died for sin. Live as truly unto God, as he lives with God. This seems to be the spirit of the apostle's meaning.”