Samuel's Mourning Over Saul's Disobedience
Samuel's Mourning Over Saul's Disobedience
The biblical account of Samuel's mourning over Saul's disobedience is rooted in 1 Samuel 15:11 and 15:35, where it is written that Samuel "cried unto the Lord all night" upon learning of Saul's failure to obey God's command to destroy the Amalekites [1, 3]. This event marked a turning point in the relationship between Samuel and Saul, as Samuel saw Saul no more until the day of his death, yet continued to mourn for him [2, 4].
The Lord's response to Samuel's mourning was to instruct him to cease his lamentation, saying, "How long wilt thou mourn for Saul, seeing I have rejected him from reigning over Israel?" [7]. This divine rebuke suggests that Samuel's grief was not merely personal but also reflected a deeper concern for the fate of Israel under Saul's leadership. According to Jamieson, Fausset & Brown, Samuel's "grief on account of Saul's rejection, accompanied, doubtless, by earnest prayers for his restitution, showed the amiable feelings of the man; but they were at variance with his public duty as a prophet" [7].
The nature of Samuel's mourning is subject to interpretation. Some commentators, like Keil & Delitzsch, suggest that Samuel mourned not only out of personal attachment to Saul but also due to anxiety for the future of Israel [8]. Matthew Henry, on the other hand, notes that God's rebuke of Samuel implies that the prophet's continued mourning was not in line with his public duty, as the rejection of Saul was a "fixed and immutable decree" [6].
The Targum Jonathan, a Jewish Rabbinic source, interprets God's instruction to Samuel to mean that he should cease mourning over Saul because God had already removed him from kingship [10]. This interpretation underscores the theological significance of Saul's rejection and the transition of leadership to another.
Flavius Josephus provides additional historical context, suggesting that Samuel's mourning was a response to the gravity of Saul's transgression and the prophet's own emotional investment in the king's fate [5]. Josephus also notes that Samuel was instructed by God to take the holy oil and go to Bethlehem to anoint a new king, marking a significant shift in Israel's leadership [5].
The verb phrase "mourned constantly" used in 1 Samuel 15:35 is typically associated with grieving over someone's death, although Saul was still living. This has led some scholars to suggest that Samuel's grief was not just for Saul's personal fate but also for the end of his reign and the implications for Israel [9].
Sources
- I Samuel “I Samuel 15:11 (Geneva1599) — It repenteth me that I haue made Saul King: for he is turned from me, and hath not performed my commandements. And Samuel was mooued, and cryed vnto the Lord all night.”
- I Samuel “I Samuel 15:35 (DRC) — And Samuel saw Saul no more till the day of his death: nevertheless, Samuel mourned for Saul, because the Lord repented that he had made him king over Israel.”
- King James Version “[KJV] 1 Kings 15:11 — It repenteth me that I have set up Saul to be king: for he is turned back from following me, and hath not performed my commandments. And it grieved Samuel; and he cried unto the LORD all night.”
- 1 Samuel “Samuel came no more to see Saul until the day of his death; for Samuel mourned for Saul: and Yahweh grieved that he had made Saul king over Israel. -- 1 Samuel 15:35”
- Project Gutenberg “Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, CHAPTER 8, section 1: . How, Upon Saul's Transgression Of The Prophet's Commands, Samuel Ordained Another Person To Be King Privately, Whose Name Was David, As God Commanded Him. 1. Now Saul being sensible of the miserable condition he had brought himself into, and that he had made God to be his enemy, he went up to his royal palace at Gibeah, which name denotes a hill, and after that day he came no more into the presence of the prophet. And when Samuel mourned for him, God bid him leave off his concern for him, and to take the holy oil, and go to Bet”
- 1 Samuel (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on 1 Samuel 16:1: Samuel had retired to his own house in Ramah, with a resolution not to appear any more in public business, but to addict himself wholly to the instructing and training up of the sons of the prophets, over whom he presided, as we find, Sa1 19:20. He promised himself more satisfaction in young prophets than in young princes; and we do not find that, to his dying day, God called him out to any public action relating to the state, but only here to anoint David. I. God reproves him for continuing so long to mourn for the rejection of Saul. He does not blame him for m”
- 1 Samuel (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Samuel 16 (introduction): SAMUEL SENT BY GOD TO BETHLEHEM. (Sa1 16:1-10) the Lord said unto Samuel, How long wilt thou mourn for Saul--Samuel's grief on account of Saul's rejection, accompanied, doubtless, by earnest prayers for his restitution, showed the amiable feelings of the man; but they were at variance with his public duty as a prophet. The declared purpose of God to transfer the kingdom of Israel into other hands than Saul's was not an angry menace, but a fixed and immutable decree; so that Samuel ought to have sooner submitted to the peremptory manifes”
- 1 Samuel (Lutheran) “Keil & Delitzsch on 1 Samuel 16:1: Anointing of David. - Sa1 16:1. The words in which God summoned Samuel to proceed to the anointing of another king, "How long wilt thou mourn for Saul, whom I have rejected, that he may not be king over Israel?" show that the prophet had not yet been able to reconcile himself to the hidden ways of the Lord; that he was still afraid that the people and kingdom of God would suffer from the rejection of Saul; and that he continued to mourn for Saul, not merely from his own personal attachment to the fallen king, but also, or perhaps still more, from anxiety for ”
- 1 Samuel (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 1 Samuel 15:35: 15:35 The verb phrase mourned constantly is usually used for grieving over someone’s death. Although Saul was still living, his royalty was coming to an end. Samuel might have been grieving out of personal attachment to Saul, a sense of failure, or concern that Israel’s condition would be worse. • the Lord was sorry: See “God’s Change of Mind” Theme Note.”
- Targum Jonathan (Jewish (Rabbinic)) “Targum Jonathan, Targum Jonathan on I Samuel 16:1: And the LORD said to Samuel, “How long will you mourn over Saul, while I have removed him from being king over Israel? Fill your horn with oil and go; I send you to Jesse, who is from Bethlehem, for there is revealed before Me among his sons one fit before Me to be the king.””