Scriptural Basis for Church Schism and Division

The concept of church schism and division is rooted in biblical teachings and has been a subject of discussion among various Christian traditions. The term "schism" refers to a separation or division within the church, often resulting from disagreements or differences in opinion ^[1].

In the New Testament, the apostle Paul addresses the issue of divisions within the church in his letters to the Corinthians. He exhorts the Corinthian believers to be united and to avoid divisions, stating that they should "all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you" (1 Cor. 1:10) ^[8]. The presence of divisions is seen as a sign of a carnal spirit, contrary to the unity of Christ (1 Cor. 1:13; 12:13) ^[3].

The biblical basis for church schism and division is further explored in the context of the Corinthian church's love feasts, where Paul notes that "there are divisions among you" (1 Cor. 11:18). The Jamieson-Fausset-Brown commentary interprets this as referring to divisions or schisms that have become inveterate, potentially leading to heresies ^{[5, 7]}.

The early church fathers also addressed the issue of schism. According to Hippolytus, Cyprian, and other patristic writers, schism is considered a grave sin, as it involves separating oneself from the unity of the church and forsaking one's bishop ^[4]. John Chrysostom, in his homilies on 1 Corinthians, emphasizes the importance of unity and the need to avoid divisions, using gentle language to rebuke the Corinthians ^[8].

The Catholic tradition, as represented by Thomas Aquinas, views schism as a special sin that is directly opposed to unity. Aquinas argues that schism is a sin that is intended to cause division, and it is considered a grave offense against the unity of the church ^[9].

In contrast, some Reformed and Baptist traditions interpret the biblical teachings on schism and division as allowing for separation from ungodly or heretical groups. John Calvin, in his Institutes, discusses the distinction between a true and a false church, arguing that the true church is characterized by its adherence to the Word of God ^[6]. John Gill, a Baptist commentator, notes that the presence of heresies and false doctrines can lead to divisions and schisms, but also acknowledges that such divisions are sometimes necessary to maintain the purity of the church ^[10].

The Methodist tradition, as represented by Adam Clarke, views the cause of divisions in the church as often resulting from the neglect or corruption of church leaders, as well as the rise of false teachers who seek to draw away disciples ^[11].

The biblical teachings on church schism and division emphasize the importance of unity and the need to avoid unnecessary divisions. While different Christian traditions have varying interpretations of these teachings, they all agree on the importance of maintaining the unity of the church.

The biblical concept of unity is closely tied to the idea of the church as the body of Christ, with Christ as its head (Eph. 1:22-23; Col. 1:18) ^[2]. The pursuit of unity is seen as a key aspect of the church's witness to the world, as Jesus prayed that his disciples might be one, "that the world may believe" (John 17:21).

Sources

Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Schism — A separation, an alienation causing divisions among Christians, who ought to be united (1 Cor. 12:25).”
Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Church, The — Belongs to God -- 1Ti 3:15. The body of Christ -- Eph 1:23; Col 1:24. Christ, the foundation-stone of -- 1Co 3:11; Eph 2:20; 1Pe 2:4,5. Christ, the head of -- Eph 1:22; 5:23. Loved by Christ -- Song 7:10; Eph 5:25. Purchased by the blood of Christ -- Ac 20:28; Eph 5:25; Heb 9:12. Sanctified and cleansed by Christ -- 1Co 6:11; Eph 5:26,27. Subject to Christ -- Ro 7:4; Eph 5:24. The object of the grace of God -- Isa 27:3; 2Co 8:1. Displays the wisdom of God -- Eph 3:10. Shows forth the praises of God -- Isa 60:6. God defends -- Ps 89:18; Isa 4:5; 49:25; M”
Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Divisions — Forbidden in the church -- 1Co 1:10. Condemned in the church -- 1Co 1:11-13; 11:18. Unbecoming in the church -- 1Co 12:24,25. Are contrary to the Unity of Christ. -- 1Co 1:13; 12:13. Desire of Christ. -- Joh 17:21-23. Purpose of Christ. -- Joh 10:16. Spirit of the church. -- 1Co 11:16. Are proof of a carnal spirit -- 1Co 3:3. Avoid those who cause -- Ro 16:17. Evil of, illustrated -- Mt 12:25.”
Schaff ANF/NPNF (Patristic) “ANF Vol 5: Hippolytus, Cyprian, Caius, Novatian — EPISTLE LXXV.(4) (part 5): he holds the unity of the Church. In fine, how inseparable is the sacrament of unity, and how hopeless are they, and what excessive ruin they earn for themselves from the indignation of God, who make a schism, and, forsaking their bishop,(1) appoint another false bishop for themselves without,--Holy Scripture declares in the books of Kings; where ten tribes were divided from the tribe of Judah and Benjamin, and, forsaking their king, appointed for themselves another one without. It says, "And the Lord was very angry w”
1 Corinthians (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Corinthians 11:18: first of all--In the first place. The "divisions" (Greek, "schisms") meant, are not merely those of opinion (Co1 1:10), but in outward acts at the love-feasts (AgapÃ&brvbr), (Co1 11:21). He does not follow up the expression, "in the first place," by "in the second place." But though not expressed, a second abuse was in his mind when he said, "In the first place," namely, THE ABUSE OF SPIRITUAL GIFTS, which also created disorder in their assemblies [ALFORD], (Co1 12:1; Co1 14:23, Co1 14:26, Co1 14:33, Co1 14:40). in the church--not the place o”
CCEL (Reformed) “John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, section 84: 2304 CHAPTER 2. COMPARISON BETWEEN THE FALSE CHURCH AND THE TRUE. The divisions of the chapter are,—I. Description of a spurious Church, resembling the Papacy vaunting of personal succession, of which a refutation is subjoined. sec. 1-4. II. An answer, in name of the orthodox Churches, to the Popish accusations of heresy and schism. A description of the Churches existing at present under the Papacy. Sections . 1. Recapitulation of the matters treated in the previous chapter. Substance of the present chapter—viz. Where lying and fal”
1 Corinthians (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Corinthians 11:19: heresies--Not merely "schisms" or "divisions" (Co1 11:18), which are "recent dissensions of the congregation through differences of opinion" [AUGUSTINE, Con. Crescon. Don. 2.7, quoted by TRENCH, Greek Synonyms of the New Testament], but also "heresies," that is, "schisms which have now become inveterate"; "Sects" [CAMPBELL, vol. 2, pp. 126, 127]: so Act 5:17; Act 15:5 translate the same Greek. At present there were dissensions at the love-feasts; but Paul, remembering Jesus' words (Mat 18:7; Mat 24:10, Mat 24:12; Luk 17:1) foresees "there must ”
CCEL/NPNF (Eastern Orthodox) “John Chrysostom, Homilies on 1 & 2 Corinthians: Homily III. 1 Cor. i. 10 Now I beseech you, brethren, through the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak of the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfected together in the same mind and in the same judgment. What I have continually been saying, that we must frame our rebukes gently and gradually, this Paul doth here also; in that, being about to enter upon a subject full of many dangers and enough to tear up the Church from her foundations he uses very mild language. His word is that he “beseeches” the”
theology (Catholic (Scholastic)) “Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part (Secunda Secundae), Of Schism, Art. 1: Article: Whether schism is a special sin? I answer that, As Isidore says (Etym. viii, 3), schism takes its name "from being a scission of minds," and scission is opposed to unity. Wherefore the sin of schism is one that is directly and essentially opposed to unity. For in the moral, as in the physical order, the species is not constituted by that which is accidental. Now, in the moral order, the essential is that which is intended, and that which results beside the intention, is, as it were, accide”
1 Corinthians (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on 1 Corinthians 11:18: For there must be also heresies among you.... This is a reason why he was ready to believe there might be something of truth in the report he had received of the divisions among them; for if there were heresies, false doctrines, and bad principles, among them, such as were subversive of the fundamentals of Christianity, as the denial of the resurrection of the dead, &c. it was no wonder that there were schisms and factions among them, since heresies generally issue in them. These, the apostle says, "must be"; because God has decreed they shall, whose counsel i”
Acts (Methodist/Wesleyan) “Adam Clarke on Acts 20:30: Also of your own selves, etc. - From out of your own assembly shall men arise, speaking perverse things, teaching for truth what is erroneous in itself, and perversive of the genuine doctrine of Christ crucified. To draw away disciples - To make schisms or rents in the Church, in order to get a party to themselves. See, here, the cause of divisions in the Church: 1. The superintendents lose the life of God, neglect the souls of the people, become greedy of gain, and, by secular extortions, oppress the people. 2. The members of the Church, thus neglected, oppressed, a”

Ask Your Own Question