Shimei's Rebellion Against King David in Scripture

Shimei, a Benjamite from Bahurim and a member of Saul's household, publicly cursed and threw stones at King David during David's flight from Absalom's rebellion ^{[1, 2, 3, 5]}. This event is recorded in 2 Samuel 16:5-13. Shimei's actions reflected the lingering resentment of Saul's family and clan towards David, whom they viewed as a usurper of their rightful possessions ^[9]. He accused David of being a "man of blood" and attributed David's misfortunes to divine retribution for the house of Saul ^[10].

As David and his entourage descended a defile, Shimei ran along a ridge, cursing and throwing stones ^{[1, 9]}. Abishai, one of David's commanders, suggested executing Shimei for his insolence, asking, "Why should this dead dog curse my lord the king? Let me go over and take off his head" (2 Samuel 16:9). However, David refused, interpreting Shimei's actions as potentially permitted by the Lord, saying, "Let him alone, and let him curse, for the Lord has told him to. It may be that the Lord will look on my affliction, and that the Lord will repay me with good for his cursing this day" (2 Samuel 16:10-12). This demonstrated David's magnanimity in a moment of personal crisis ^[14]. The location of Bahurim, Shimei's home, was significant, as it was also where Ahimaaz and Jonathan later hid during Absalom's pursuit, symbolizing both David's decline and the hope for his resurgence ^[12].

After Absalom's defeat and David's return to power, Shimei was among the first to seek the king's pardon ^{[2, 15]}. He hurried with a thousand Benjamites to meet David at the Jordan River, prostrating himself and pleading for forgiveness ^{[6, 8, 14]}. Shimei expressed deep regret for his previous conduct, acknowledging his sin and asking David not to hold it against him ^{[8, 14]}. Once again, Abishai urged David to execute Shimei for cursing the Lord's anointed ^[14]. However, David, in a display of mercy and a desire to consolidate his kingdom, swore an oath that Shimei would not be put to death that day ^[16]. Josephus records that Shimei "took hold of his feet, and prayed him to forgive him what he had done" ^[8].

Despite David's pardon, the matter of Shimei's past actions was not entirely forgotten. On his deathbed, David instructed his son Solomon to deal with Shimei, reminding him of the wickedness Shimei had committed ^{[4, 11]}. David's instruction to Solomon was not an act of vengeance but a pragmatic move to secure the stability of his successor's reign by removing potential threats ^[16].

Upon ascending the throne, Solomon summoned Shimei and confined him to Jerusalem, forbidding him from crossing the Kidron Valley or leaving the city on pain of death ^{[11, 13]}. Shimei agreed to these terms and lived in Jerusalem for three years ^[11]. However, when two of his servants ran away to Gath, Shimei violated his oath by leaving Jerusalem to retrieve them ^{[7, 13]}. Solomon, upon learning of this, confronted Shimei, reminding him of his past treachery against David and his broken oath to the Lord ^{[4, 7, 13]}. Consequently, Solomon ordered Benaiah to execute Shimei, thus bringing an end to the threat he posed to the Davidic dynasty ^[13]. This final act ensured that Shimei's earlier rebellion and subsequent perjury were met with justice, solidifying Solomon's rule ^{[11, 13]}.

Sources

Smith's Bible Dictionary “Smith's Bible Dictionary: Shimei — (renowned). + Son of Gershon the son of Levi, (Numbers 3:18; 1 Chronicles 6:17,29; 23:7,9,10; Zechariah 12:13) called [1121]Shimi in (Exodus 6:17) (B.C. after 1706.) + Shimei the son of Gera, a Benjamite of the house of Saul, who lived at Bahurim. (B.C. 1023.) When David and his suite were seen descending the long defile, on his flight from Absolom, (2 Samuel 16:5-13) the whole feeling of the clan of Benjamin burst forth without restraint in the person of Shimei. He ran along the ridge, cursing and throwing stones at the king and is companions. The next meeti”
Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Shimei — Famous. (1.) A son of Gershon, and grandson of Levi (Num. 3:18; 1 Chr. 6:17, 29); called Shimi in Ex. 6:17. (2.) A Benjamite of the house of Saul, who stoned and cursed David when he reached Bahurim in his flight from Jerusalem on the occasion of the rebellion of Absalom (2 Sam. 16:5-13). After the defeat of Absalom he "came cringing to the king, humbly suing for pardon, bringing with him a thousand of his Benjamite tribesmen, and representing that he was heartily sorry for his crime, and had hurried the first of all the house of Israel to offer homage to th”
2 Samuel “When king David came to Bahurim, behold, a man of the family of the house of Saul came out, whose name was Shimei, the son of Gera. He came out, and cursed still as he came. -- 2 Samuel 16:5”
1 Kings “The king said moreover to Shimei, “You know all the wickedness which your heart is privy to, that you did to David my father. Therefore Yahweh shall return your wickedness on your own head. -- 1 Kings 2:44”
II Samuel “II Samuel 16:5 (YLT) — And king David hath come in unto Bahurim, and lo, thence a man is coming out, of the family of the house of Saul, and his name <FI>is<Fi> Shimei, son of Gera, he cometh out, coming out and reviling;”
II Samuel “II Samuel 19:16 (BSB) — Then Shimei son of Gera, a Benjamite from Bahurim, hurried down with the men of Judah to meet King David,”
Project Gutenberg “Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, CHAPTER 1, section 4: that two of his servants were run away from him, and were in Gath, he went for his servants in haste; and when he was come back with them, the king perceived it, and was much displeased that he had contemned his commands, and, what was more, had no regard to the oaths he had sworn to God; so he called him, and said to him, "Didst not thou swear never to leave me, nor to go out of this city to another? Thou shalt not therefore escape punishment for thy perjury, but I will punish thee, thou wicked wretch, both for this crime, and f”
Project Gutenberg “Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, CHAPTER 11, section 2: And Shimei, the son of Gera, came with a thousand men, which he brought with him out of the tribe of Benjamin; and Ziba, the freed-man of Saul, with his sons, fifteen in number, and with his twenty servants. All these, as well as the tribe of Judah, laid a bridge [of boats] over the river, that the king, and those that were with him, might with ease pass over it. Now as soon as he was come to Jordan, the tribe of Judah saluted him. Shimei also came upon the bridge, and took hold of his feet, and prayed him to forgive him what he”
2 Samuel (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 2 Samuel 16:5: SHIMEI CURSES DAVID. (Sa2 16:5-19) when king David came to Bahurim--a city of Benjamin (Sa2 3:16; Sa2 19:16). It is, however, only the confines of the district that are here meant. Shimei, . . . a man of the family of Saul--The misfortune of his family, and the occupation by David of what they considered their rightful possessions, afforded a natural, if not a justifiable cause for this ebullition of rude insults and violence. He upbraided David as an ambitious usurper, and charged him, as one whose misdeeds had recoiled upon his own head, to surr”
2 Samuel (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 2 Samuel 16:7: 16:7-8 Shimei cursed David, holding him responsible for the violent death of Saul and his clan.”
1 Kings (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Kings 2:36: the king sent and called for Shimei--He was probably residing at Bahurim, his native place. But, as he was a suspicious character, Solomon condemned him henceforth to live in Jerusalem, on the penalty of death, for going without the gates. He submitted to this confinement for three years, when, violating his oath, he was arrested and put to death by Solomon for perjury, aggravated by his former crime of high treason against David [Kg1 2:42-44].”
2 Samuel (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 2 Samuel 17:18: 17:18-20 Bahurim was the home of Shimei, the pro-Saul Benjaminite (16:5; 19:16). Shimei’s cursing of David at Bahurim reflected David’s decline, while the escape of Ahimaaz and Jonathan pictured the hope of David’s resurgence.”
1 Kings (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 1 Kings 2:39: 2:39-46 Shimei’s journey to Gath, ostensibly to recover his runaway slaves, violated his agreement. Technically, he did not cross the Kidron Valley in going to Gath, but the penalty was understood by both parties to apply to Shimei’s going anywhere else. Because Shimei violated his oath to the Lord (2:43) and because of his past hostilities toward David (2 Sam 16:5-13; 19:16-23), Solomon instructed Benaiah to execute him.”
2 Samuel (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 2 Samuel 19:16: Shemei . . . a thousand men of Benjamin with him--This display of [Shemei's] followers was to show what force he could raise against or in support of the king. Expressing the deepest regret for his former outrageous conduct, he was pardoned on the spot; and although the son of Zeruiah urged the expediency of making this chief a public example, his officiousness was repulsed by David with magnanimity, and with the greater confidence that he felt himself now re-established in the kingdom (see on Kg1 2:8).”
2 Samuel (Baptist/Reformed) “John Gill on 2 Samuel 19:16: And Shimei the son of Gera, a Benjamite, which was of Bahurim,.... Of whom see Sa2 16:5, hasted and came down with the men of Judah to meet King David: he took the first opportunity to meet the king, and ask his pardon for his ill treatment of him when he fled from Jerusalem; for, hearing: that Absalom was slain, and the victory was on the side of David, who was returning in triumph, he thought it advisable as soon as possible to make his submission, and entreat forgiveness, lest he should fall a just sacrifice to his vengeance; and a better opportunity he could ”
2 Samuel (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 2 Samuel 19:15: 19:15-23 On his return to Jerusalem, David showed mercy to Shimei, the pro-Saul northerner who had cursed David when he fled from Jerusalem (see 16:5-14), but Shimei’s action did not go unpunished (1 Kgs 2:8, 36-46). 19:15 Gilgal was an important city in the days of Samuel and Saul (see study note on 19:40; 1 Sam 7:16; 11:15).”

Ask Your Own Question