Testing the Spirits and Identifying False Prophets

The biblical injunction to "test the spirits" originates in 1 John 4:1, where believers are exhorted not to believe every spirit but to discern whether they are from God, "because many false prophets have gone out into the world" ^{[1, 2]}. This directive is part of a broader biblical concern with distinguishing true from false prophecy and teaching.

The biblical text identifies false prophets as those who claim to speak on behalf of God but are not actually commissioned or sent by Him ^[3]. In the Old Testament, false prophets are described as covetous, immoral, and influenced by evil spirits (Mic 3:11; 1 Ki 22:21-22). The practice of divination, associated with false prophecy, is condemned in Deuteronomy 18:10-14 and elsewhere ^[4].

In 1 John 4, the test for discerning the origin of a spirit involves assessing whether it acknowledges Jesus Christ come in the flesh. According to the Tyndale House commentary, this test is part of a broader criterion that includes adherence to the teachings of the apostles ^[7]. The Spirit of truth, identified as the Holy Spirit, teaches the truth about Christ, while the spirit of deception leads people away from Christ (1 Jn 2:20, 27; John 14:17, 26; 15:26; 16:13-15) ^[7].

The early Christian tradition emphasized the importance of discernment. John Chrysostom, in his Homilies on Galatians–Colossians–Thessalonians, notes that the gift of "discerning of spirits" was given to the Church to counter the devil's attempts to subvert the gift of prophecy ^[9]. one commentary tradition by Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Thessalonians 5:21 similarly highlights the need to test all manifestations of the Spirit, using the means of testing available in the Church, including the "discerning of spirits" (1 Cor 12:10; 1 Cor 14:29) ^[8].

The Nonconformist/Puritan tradition, represented by Matthew Henry, interprets 1 John 4:1 as a call to caution against false prophets and teachers, emphasizing the need for scrutiny and discernment among believers ^[6]. Henry's commentary on Matthew 7:15 also warns against false prophets, understood as false teachers, highlighting the importance of being aware of their presence and influence ^[10].

The tests for identifying false prophets and discerning the spirits involve both doctrinal criteria, such as the acknowledgment of Jesus Christ, and the fruit of the Spirit in a person's life. According to the Tyndale House commentary on 1 John 4:1-6, these tests are not exhaustive but provide a starting point for true teachers to distinguish themselves from false ones ^[11].

The historical development of the doctrine of testing the spirits is closely tied to the early Christian controversies over false prophecy and teaching. The apostolic writings, including 1 John, provide the foundational criteria for discernment, while the patristic and Reformation traditions further articulate the importance of testing the spirits in the context of the Church's ongoing life and mission.

The practice of testing the spirits remains a vital aspect of Christian discipleship, requiring believers to be vigilant and discerning in the face of various spiritual claims and influences. As the biblical text and the Christian tradition make clear, this discernment is not limited to ecclesiastical leaders but is a responsibility shared among all believers ^[5].

Sources

I John “I John 4:1 (LEB) — Dear friends, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to determine if they are from God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world.”
1 John “1 John 4:1 (NASB) — Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world.”
Torrey's Topical Textbook “Torrey's Topical Textbook: Prophets, False — Pretended to be sent by God -- Jer 23:17,18,31. Not sent or commissioned by God -- Jer 14:14; 23:21; 29:31. Made use of by God to prove Israel -- De 13:3. Described as Light and treacherous. -- Zep 3:4. Covetous. -- Mic 3:11. Crafty. -- Mt 7:15. Drunken. -- Isa 28:7. Immoral and profane. -- Jer 23:11,14. Women sometimes acted as -- Ne 6:14; Re 2:20. Called foolish prophets -- Eze 13:2. Compared to foxes in the desert -- Eze 13:4. Compared to wind -- Jer 5:13. Influenced by evil spirits -- 1Ki 22:21,22. Prophesied Falsely. -- Jer 5:31. Lies in the na”
Easton's Bible Dictionary “Easton's Bible Dictionary: Divination — Of false prophets (Deut. 18:10, 14; Micah 3:6, 7, 11), of necromancers (1 Sam. 28:8), of the Philistine priests and diviners (1 Sam. 6:2), of Balaam (Josh. 13:22). Three kinds of divination are mentioned in Ezek. 21:21, by arrows, consulting with images (the teraphim), and by examining the entrails of animals sacrificed. The practice of this art seems to have been encouraged in ancient Egypt. Diviners also abounded among the aborigines of Canaan and the Philistines (Isa. 2:6; 1 Sam. 28). At a later period multitudes of magicians poured from Chaldea and A”
1 John (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 John 4 (introduction): TESTS OF FALSE PROPHETS. LOVE, THE TEST OF BIRTH FROM GOD, AND THE NECESSARY FRUIT OF KNOWING HIS GREAT LOVE IN CHRIST TO US. (1Jo. 4:1-21) Beloved--the affectionate address wherewith he calls their attention, as to an important subject. every spirit--which presents itself in the person of a prophet. The Spirit of truth, and the spirit of error, speak by men's spirits as their organs. There is but one Spirit of truth, and one spirit of Antichrist. try--by the tests (Jo1 4:2-3). All believers are to do so: not merely ecclesiastics. Even”
1 John (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on 1 John 4:1: The apostle, having said that God's dwelling in and with us may be known by the Spirit that he hath given us, intimates that that Spirit may be discerned and distinguished from other spirits that appear in the world; and so here, I. He calls the disciples, to whom he writes, to caution and scrutiny about the spirits and spiritual professors that had now risen. 1. To caution: "Beloved, believe not every spirit; regard not, trust not, follow not, every pretender to the Spirit of God, or every professor of vision, or inspiration, or revelation from God." Truth is the ”
1 John (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 1 John 4:6: 4:6 John tests the reality of a person’s Christianity by whether they listen to and agree with the teachings of the apostles. • The Spirit of truth is the Holy Spirit (John 14:17, 26; 15:26; 16:13-15), who teaches the truth about Christ (1 Jn 2:20, 27). • False prophets have the spirit of deception, the spirit of antichrist, which leads people away from Christ (see study note on 2:22). Therefore, union with the historic body of Christ and the consensus of teaching that began with the apostles is a sign of fidelity to Christ’s work in the world.”
1 Thessalonians (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Thessalonians 5:21: Some of the oldest manuscripts insert "But." You ought indeed not to "quench" the manifestations of "the Spirit," nor "despise prophesyings"; "but," at the same time, do not take "all" as genuine which professes to be so; "prove (test) all" such manifestations. The means of testing them existed in the Church, in those who had the "discerning of spirits" (Co1 12:10; Co1 14:29; Jo1 4:1). Another sure test, which we also have, is, to try the professed revelation whether it accords with Scripture, as the noble Bereans did (Isa 8:20; Act 17:11; Gal”
CCEL/NPNF (Eastern Orthodox) “John Chrysostom, Homilies on Galatians–Colossians–Thessalonians: is dry, whatever is warm, whatever is fiery, kindles the flame of the Spirit. Let us not therefore overlay it with anything cold or damp; for these things are destructive of it. But there is also another explanation. There were among them many indeed who prophesied truly, but some prophesied falsely. This also he says in the Epistle to the Corinthians, that on this account He gave “the discernings of spirits.” ( 1 Cor. xii. 10 .) For the devil, of his vile craft, wished through this gift of grace to subvert everything pertaining ”
Matthew (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Matthew 7:15: We have here a caution against false prophets, to take heed that we be not deceived and imposed upon by them. Prophets are properly such as foretel things to come; there are some mentioned in the Old Testament, who pretended to that without warrant, and the event disproved their pretensions, as Zedekiah, Kg1 22:11, and another Zedekiah, Jer 29:21. But prophets did also teach the people their duty, so that false prophets here are false teachers. Christ being a Prophet and a Teacher come from God, and designing to send abroad teachers under him, gives warning to al”
1 John (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on 1 John 4:1: 4:1-6 Those who belong to God (4:4) can distinguish spiritual truth from error, because the Spirit’s presence (3:23-24) teaches them (see 2:20, 27; John 14:15-26; 16:5-15). Yet John provides concrete tests for the believers to apply so that there will be no confusion. These tests are a starting point for true teachers, not an exhaustive set; they were designed to address the false teachings that were being promoted in the churches of John’s readers. 4:1 everyone who claims to speak by the Spirit (literally every spirit): The teachers who left John’s churches claime”

Ask Your Own Question