Using Scripture to Critique Human Examples in Teaching

When evaluating human examples used in teaching and preaching, it is essential to critique and correct them through the lens of Scripture. Paul writes in Romans 8:28 that "all things work together for good" for those who love God, reminding us that even flawed human examples can be used to illustrate biblical truths. However, this does not mean that we should accept or promote unscriptural teachings or methods. Rather, we must carefully examine each example in light of Scripture, recognizing that human wisdom and experience, though valuable, are ultimately subordinate to God's Word.

This approach is rooted in the Reformed principle of sola Scriptura, which affirms that Scripture alone is the final authority in all matters of faith and practice. By holding human examples up to the standard of Scripture, we can identify and correct any errors or inconsistencies, ensuring that our teaching and preaching are grounded in biblical truth. This is particularly important in the context of preaching, where the goal is not to promote human wisdom or experience, but to proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ and the truths of Scripture.

In critiquing human examples, we must also be mindful of the potential for idolatry, where human teachers or leaders are elevated to a position of undue authority. By contrast, Scripture teaches us to look to Christ as our ultimate example and authority, and to evaluate all human teachings and examples in light of His Word. This approach helps to guard against the dangers of pragmatism and subjectivism, and ensures that our teaching and preaching are centered on the gospel and the glory of God.